Dairy Hub

Nutrition, Feed & Forage

Is Alfalfa Worth Growing on Your Dairy

Mixer wagon feeding dairy cows

Alfalfa is worth growing when your soil, climate and equipment let you get a good stand and harvest it on time. When they do not, it is a fussy plant that will remind you of every missed cutting. The honest answer is that it depends, and the deciding factors are drainage, soil pH, and whether you can make hay or baleage when the weather has other plans.

The reason dairies keep trying is simple. Good alfalfa gives you home-grown protein and effective fiber in the same bite, and the cows eat it like it owes them money. That can trim purchased protein and keep the ration working. Here is how to tell whether it pencils out on your farm.

What alfalfa actually gives a dairy ration

Alfalfa is a legume, so it makes its own nitrogen and carries a lot of crude protein for a forage. Compared with corn silage, which is mostly energy, alfalfa brings protein, calcium and a fiber that cows chew and ruminate on. The two crops balance each other, which is why so many Upper Midwest and Northeast rations are built on both.

Quality swings with maturity and harvest weather. Early-cut, leafy alfalfa tests high in protein and digestible fiber. Late-cut, stemmy alfalfa tests more like a mattress. That gap is why cutting schedules matter as much as the seed you buy, and why you want a lab number rather than a guess. If the abbreviations on a forage report make your eyes glaze, reading a forage test sorts out what the lab is telling you.

The legume bonus

Because alfalfa fixes its own nitrogen, it can also give the following corn crop a nitrogen credit, and the deep taproot can break up compacted layers. Neither effect is magic and both depend on stand age and soil, but they are real parts of the rotation math.

What it takes to grow it

Alfalfa is picky about its home. It wants well-drained soil, a pH near neutral, and adequate fertility, especially potassium, phosphorus and sulfur on many soils. It does not like wet feet. A field that stays soggy in spring will thin out, and no amount of optimism will change that. Boron can matter on lighter soils. A soil test before you plant is the cheapest money you will spend.

  • Good fit: deep, well-drained loams, with lime history and a field that dries in spring.
  • Poor fit: heavy, poorly drained clay, acid ground you do not plan to lime, or fields prone to ponding.
  • Borderline: sandy ground in dry regions, which can work under irrigation but pays in water and fertilizer.

Establishment is where many stands are won or lost. Seed goes shallow into a firm seedbed, and weed control in the first months matters because baby alfalfa is a poor competitor. Whether you seed with a companion crop or straight is a call for your agronomist, and your land-grant forage team publishes seeding guides tuned to your region. The University of Wisconsin alfalfa page collects variety, seeding and management information that carries over to many other northern states.

The costs and risks

Alfalfa is not cheap up front. Seed, lime and fertilizer, tillage or no-till seeding, weed control, and a year with limited yield all show up before the first good cutting. The payback comes over several seasons, which is why stand life is the number that matters most. A stand that lasts only a couple of years can be a poor deal. One that stays productive for several is a different story.

Risks worth naming:

  • Winterkill. Cold, ice sheeting, and poor drainage thin stands in northern states. Fall management, including how late you cut, affects winter survival.
  • Insects and disease. Alfalfa weevil, potato leafhopper and root diseases vary by region and year. Scouting beats surprise.
  • Weather during harvest. Alfalfa dries slower than grass, and a rained-on windrow loses leaves and quality fast. The leaves are where the protein is.
  • Bloat risk on pasture. Fresh legume pasture can cause bloat in grazing animals, so grazers should have a plan and talk to their vet.

Wheel traffic hurts too. Every pass with a heavy tractor or wagon crushes crowns and thins the stand along the tracks, and you will see those stripes for the rest of the stand's life like a bad haircut.

Harvest options matter more than you think

Making dry hay in humid regions is a coin flip. Many dairies in the Northeast, the Southeast and the wetter parts of the Midwest harvest alfalfa as wilted haylage in a bunker or bag, or as wrapped bales, which shortens field drying and lowers weather risk. Wrapping baleage at the right moisture is one route for small farms without a chopper. In drier regions, such as the Mountain West and Southwest, dry hay can be made on a tight schedule, and irrigated alfalfa can yield many cuttings.

If you do not have the machinery and labor to hit those windows, a custom harvester can fill the gap, though the bill needs to be part of your math. For a rainy cut, making dairy-quality hay in a wet summer covers what you can still save.

Doing the math for your own farm

Do not compare alfalfa's price per ton to a bag of supplement and call it done. Walk through the full picture:

  1. Cost per acre to establish, spread across the expected life of the stand.
  2. Annual cost of fertility, weed and insect control, and harvest.
  3. Likely yield and quality, using your own fields or neighbors' records rather than the seed catalog.
  4. What you would otherwise buy: protein, fiber, and forage in the form of purchased hay or alternative crops.
  5. What the acres would otherwise grow. Corn silage may yield more energy per acre, but you may need to purchase protein to balance it.

A nutritionist can run these numbers against your ration, and a conversation with a dairy nutritionist may save you from a strong opinion based on a single bad year. Some farms find that growing alfalfa on the best fields and buying the rest is the right mix. Others decide that buying high-quality hay from a neighbor who loves the crop is cheaper than fighting a stand they do not.

Either answer is fine. The mistake is planting it because a grandfather always did, or avoiding it because he complained about it.

Quick answers

How long does an alfalfa stand last?

It varies by variety, soil, climate and management. Many stands stay productive for several years, and then yields decline and growers rotate to corn. Good drainage and sensible cutting dates help stands last longer.

Can alfalfa be grown organically for dairy?

Yes, and it fits well since it supplies its own nitrogen. Organic rules require specific field histories and practices, so check with your certifier and USDA organic standards before planting.

Is alfalfa better than grass hay for dairy cows?

For milking cows, alfalfa usually offers more protein and energy than mature grass hay. Grass has its place in dry cow and heifer diets, and in wet or acid fields where alfalfa will not survive.

More from farm.FM Need a break from the paperwork? Farm humor and funny farm stories are always in season at farm.FM.