Reading a Forage Test: RFV, RFQ, NDF and Beyond

A forage report is a page of abbreviations that your nutritionist reads like a menu and you read like a tax form. The short version: fiber numbers (NDF and ADF) tell you how much a cow can eat and how much energy she will get, digestibility tells you how much of that fiber she will actually use, and protein and ash tell you what else came along for the ride.
You do not need to memorize the whole page. You need to know which four or five numbers move the milk check, which ones are only there to look impressive, and how to line up two lots side by side without comparing apples to a tarp.
Start with one rule that saves arguments: always compare on a dry matter basis. A haylage that looks like it has 12 percent protein as sampled might be 18 percent on a dry basis, and the cow does not care about the water.
The numbers that matter most
NDF: how much she can eat
Neutral detergent fiber is the bulk of the plant wall: cellulose, hemicellulose and lignin. Higher NDF generally means more fill, so a cow hits her rumen capacity sooner and eats less dry matter. For a fresh cow on a short fuse for intake, a lower-NDF forage is worth real money. For a late-lactation cow with room to spare, a stemmy hay is not a crime.
ADF: a rough energy clue
Acid detergent fiber is the less digestible part of the fiber, mostly cellulose and lignin. As ADF climbs, energy tends to drop. It is the number older hay markets leaned on because it was cheap to run, and it still works as a quick screen. It just does not tell the whole story, which is why the next number exists.
NDFD: how much of the fiber she actually uses
Neutral detergent fiber digestibility, usually reported at 30 or 48 hours of lab fermentation, tells you how much of that fiber gets broken down. Two corn silages can show the same NDF and perform very differently because one hybrid has stalks that rumen bugs can chew through and the other does not. If your lab offers NDFD, pay for it. It is one of the few numbers on the page that explains why a ration changed when the feed "tested the same."
Crude protein, ash and the supporting cast
Crude protein matters for budgeting soybean meal or other protein sources. Ash is the quiet one: a high ash number in hay or silage often means soil came in with the crop from a low cutter bar, wheel tracks or a flooded field. Dirt carries no energy and can bring clostridial spores with it, so a spike in ash is worth a second look. Starch matters for corn silage and shows up with a kernel processing score on some labs.
RFV vs RFQ: the index scores
Relative feed value (RFV) combines estimated digestibility from ADF and intake potential from NDF into one number. A reference full-bloom alfalfa sits at 100, and better forage scores higher. It is simple, it has sold a lot of hay, and it has one weakness: it ignores whether the fiber is digestible. A grass hay and an alfalfa hay can post the same RFV and feed very differently.
Relative forage quality (RFQ) was built to fix that. It uses digestible fiber and estimated total digestible nutrients, so it can compare legumes, grasses and mixed stands more fairly. Many hay auctions and labs now report both. If you are buying hay for lactating cows, RFQ is the better yardstick, and if the seller only quotes RFV, ask what the NDFD was.
Another useful index is milk per ton, which estimates milk from the energy and intake potential of the forage. The University of Wisconsin published a good explanation of the milk per ton index for alfalfa and grass that spells out what it uses and where it falls short. Treat any index as a ranking tool, not a ration.
Wet chemistry vs NIR
Most routine reports use near-infrared spectroscopy, which is fast, cheap and good enough for most decisions. Wet chemistry runs the actual lab procedures and costs more. Use wet chemistry when the stakes rise: a big purchase, a silage that does not fit its calibration, or a sample with odd ingredients like heavy molasses or a lot of weeds. If two labs disagree by a lot on the same sample, call and ask which method each one used before anyone loses sleep.
None of it works without a good sample. A report on a bad grab sample is a precise number about the wrong feed, so read how to sample forage for a lab analysis before you blame the lab.
Silage reports: the fermentation panel
Silage reports add a fermentation section. It answers a different question: did the crop ferment cleanly, or did something else get there first?
- pH: lower is generally better for stable silage, though the target depends on moisture. Wetter silage needs a lower pH to stay stable.
- Lactic acid: the main product you want, ideally well ahead of acetic acid.
- Acetic acid: some is normal. A lot of it points to a heterofermentative fermentation, which can be fine, but very high numbers can cut intake.
- Butyric acid: the red flag. It signals clostridial fermentation, usually from wet or dirty forage, and it tends to come with lost dry matter and poor intake.
- Ammonia-N or soluble protein: a high share of protein broken down during storage suggests more protein degradation than you wanted.
Pair these numbers with what you see and smell at the bunker. A silage that tests fine and smells like a barn fire is trying to tell you something the lab did not measure.
Comparing two lots: a quick method
- Put both reports on a dry matter basis.
- Compare NDF and NDFD first, because they drive intake and energy.
- Check ADF or total digestible nutrients as a second opinion on energy.
- Look at crude protein and what it would cost to replace the gap with purchased protein.
- Scan ash for contamination and the fermentation panel for silage problems.
- Divide the price per ton by the dry matter percentage to get a price per ton of dry matter.
That last step is where bargains and rip-offs reveal themselves. A cheap wet bale can cost more per pound of actual feed than a pricey dry one. If you are building a cost picture for the whole herd, calculating feed cost per hundredweight of milk shows where forage fits in the bigger number.
Mistakes that make the report useless
- Sampling one bale because it was on top and easy to reach.
- Comparing an as-fed number to a dry matter number and declaring a winner.
- Chasing the highest RFV while ignoring NDFD, ash and mold.
- Never retesting stored silage. Feed changes as it ferments and as the face moves into a different part of the field or load.
- Handing the report to the nutritionist and never looking at it yourself. They are good, but they also do not own the cows.
A forage test cannot see mold or mycotoxins in any meaningful way, and drought-stressed corn can carry nitrate that a standard panel will not flag, so ask for those tests specifically when conditions call for it. The signs of mycotoxins in dairy feed are worth knowing before you need them. When a report leaves you stuck, a good nutritionist earns the fee, and hiring a dairy nutritionist covers what to expect. For a broader look at forage topics from a land-grant program, the University of Wisconsin forage production and management hub is a solid place to keep bookmarked.
Quick answers
What is a good RFV for dairy hay?
It depends on the cows. High-producing and fresh cows usually need higher-quality alfalfa, while dry cows and heifers do fine on lower-scoring hay. Ask your nutritionist for a target that matches your ration instead of chasing a number someone read on a sale bill.
Is RFQ better than RFV?
For comparing mixed or grass-heavy forages, generally yes, because RFQ accounts for fiber digestibility and RFV does not. For a quick ranking of straight alfalfa, RFV still gets you most of the way there.
How often should I test forage?
Test every new lot, every new field or cutting, and again when silage changes at the face or the weather shifts the harvest. Many herds test silage on a regular schedule through feeding season so the ration follows the feed instead of lagging behind it.