Dairy Hub

Grazing, Organic & Small Dairies

Treating Sick Cows on an Organic Dairy: What Is Allowed

Jersey cows grazing in clover pasture

The organic rules on sick cows come down to one idea that surprises many farmers who are new to the system: you must treat a sick animal, even if the treatment means she can no longer be part of your organic herd. The cow comes first. The label comes second.

That doesn't mean organic dairies reach for the drug box first. The regulations lean heavily on prevention, and a lot of treatment on organic farms uses allowed materials, supportive care and good barn management. When a cow needs something that's not allowed, though, you give it to her, identify her, and take her out of organic milk production.

This article is general education on how the federal rules work. It does not cover drugs, doses or protocols, and every treatment decision belongs to your herd veterinarian and your certifier.

Prevention comes first

The rule for care and production practices is 7 CFR 205.238. It requires organic producers to establish and maintain preventive health care, including:

  • Choosing species and types of livestock suited to site conditions and resistant to prevalent diseases and parasites.
  • Feeding a ration that meets nutritional needs.
  • Housing, pasture conditions and sanitation that minimize disease and parasites.
  • Conditions that allow exercise, freedom of movement and reduced stress.
  • Vaccines and other veterinary biologics.
  • Monitoring lameness and treating it in a timely, appropriate way, and mitigating its causes.

That list is also a decent description of a well-run dairy of any kind. A clean calving pen, good teat prep and dry cow management reduce the number of cows who need anything beyond hay and a pat on the neck. Signs of mastitis and when to call the vet for a sick cow are worth knowing in either system.

What's allowed, in general terms

When prevention isn't enough, an organic producer may use medications that are on the National List of allowed synthetic substances, found in USDA's National List materials, to relieve pain or suffering, but only in the presence of illness. Some listed substances come with conditions such as a prescription requirement or a longer withdrawal time. The eOrganic summary of approved health care and medication regulations for organic dairy and livestock lists some examples of allowed materials, including ethanol and isopropanol as disinfectants and aspirin, and notes that using them without following their restrictions can cost you certification. The list changes over time, so confirm with your certifier and your vet before you rely on any item.

Other points from the same section:

  • Vaccines and biologics are part of preventive care.
  • Synthetic parasiticides can't be used routinely, and the rules limit where and when allowed ones may be used.
  • Hormones for growth, production or reproduction are generally prohibited, apart from specific uses listed in the National List.
  • Animal drugs used in violation of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act are prohibited, which is true for every dairy, organic or not.

What ends organic status for the cow

The same section says an organic operation must not sell, label or represent as organic any animal or product from an animal treated with antibiotics, a synthetic substance not allowed on the National List, or a prohibited non-synthetic substance. In practice:

SituationWhat the rule says about the milk
Treated with an allowed synthetic that has a withdrawal periodMilk can't be sold, labeled or represented as organic during the withdrawal period; it may be fed to calves on the same operation
Treated with a prohibited substance (such as an antibiotic)Milk can't be sold as organic, and can't be fed to organic livestock; the animal must be identified and neither she nor her products can be sold or labeled organic
Treated with an allowed non-drug approach (preventive, supportive, allowed material)Milk generally stays organic, subject to any conditions on the material

Both of those rows come from the text of 7 CFR 205.238(c). Because the details of what happens to the cow next (sale, separation, whether she stays on the farm) depend on your organic system plan and certifier, ask in advance, not after the vet leaves.

You can't withhold treatment

This is the part that protects animals. The rules prohibit withholding medical treatment from a sick animal to preserve her organic status. All appropriate medications must be used to restore an animal to health when methods acceptable to organic production fail. The rule also prohibits withholding individual treatment designed to minimize pain and suffering for injured, diseased or sick animals, which can include euthanasia as recommended by the American Veterinary Medical Association.

If you've been tempted to leave a sick cow alone because she's your best organic producer, the rule says no, and so does common decency. A cow in pain doesn't know she's on the organic list, and has never once read the National List. Treat her, document it, and move on. A cow that needs an antibiotic and gets one is a cow in better shape than one that doesn't, and one cow leaving the organic string is a smaller problem than a dead cow.

Record everything

The rules also prohibit neglecting to identify and record treatment of sick and injured animals in the animal health records. For each treatment, most certifiers expect you to log:

  1. The animal's ID and the date.
  2. What was wrong.
  3. What was given, by whom, and on what veterinary advice.
  4. Whether the material is allowed under the organic rules.
  5. Withdrawal and milk discard dates, if any.
  6. Where the milk went during that time, and what happened to the cow.

Treated animals must be clearly identified, with leg bands, tags or paint, whatever your system uses, and treated cows should be milked last or separately so milk doesn't get into the bulk tank. Milking order for fresh and treated cows goes over the routine, and keeping treatment records that pass an inspection is a good template. For general milk safety rules that apply on every dairy, organic or not, see antibiotic withdrawal times and milk discard rules and preventing antibiotic residues in the bulk tank.

Working with your vet and certifier

A vet who knows organic rules is valuable, and a vet who doesn't can still help if you share your organic system plan. Before a crisis:

  • Sit down with the vet and the certifier's list of allowed materials, and decide in advance what you'll use for the common problems on your farm.
  • Ask the vet which treatments carry withdrawal periods and how the certifier wants them handled.
  • Keep the vet-client relationship current, as in the veterinary client patient relationship on dairies.
  • Put the vet's number on the milk house wall, not only in a phone that's in the truck. Decide ahead of time what happens to a cow who needs a prohibited treatment: where she's housed, how she's identified, and where she goes next.

The point of making the plan in advance is to avoid making it at 2 a.m. with a sick cow and a phone.

Regional notes

The federal rules are the same across the country, but how easy it is to find an organic-savvy vet is not. In the Northeast and Upper Midwest, with more organic dairies, vets with experience are easier to find. In other regions, you may need to educate the vet or find an extension specialist or certifier staff who can help. Heat, humidity and parasite pressure in the Southeast also change what you're likely to be treating. If your handler has additional requirements beyond the federal rules, follow the stricter set.

Quick answers

Can an organic cow be given antibiotics?

Yes, if she needs them, because the rules forbid withholding treatment. But the cow and her milk can no longer be sold as organic once she's been treated with an antibiotic, and she must be identified. Your vet and certifier will guide how that works on your farm.

What happens to the milk from a treated organic cow?

Milk from a cow treated with a prohibited substance can't be sold as organic or fed to organic livestock. Milk from a cow treated with an allowed material that has a withholding time can't be sold as organic during that period, but may be fed to calves on the same operation. Other milk safety and discard rules apply as well.

Do I have to tell my certifier about a treatment?

You have to record every treatment in the animal health records, and your certifier reviews those records. Ask how they want treatments that remove an animal from organic production reported, and put it in your organic system plan.

More from farm.FM Need a break from the paperwork? Farm humor and funny farm stories are always in season at farm.FM.