Dairy Hub

Milk Markets, Co-ops & Processing

What Is a Make Allowance in Milk Pricing?

Cheese aging in a creamery and a milk tanker

A make allowance is a deduction. When USDA turns wholesale cheese, butter, nonfat dry milk and dry whey prices into the minimum prices a plant owes for milk, it first subtracts a set amount per pound to cover what the plant spends turning milk into those products. That amount is the make allowance. The bigger it is, the smaller the milk price that comes out the other end.

That's why the topic gets people riled up at co-op annual meetings. Processors say their costs have climbed and the allowance should follow. Producers say every cent added to the allowance is a cent that leaves the farm, because it comes straight off the price paid for components. Both sides are describing the same number, which is how you know it's a real argument.

What "make" means

"Make" is dairy shorthand for manufacturing. The make cost is everything the plant spends to convert raw milk into a saleable commodity: labor, energy, packaging, cultures and rennet, wastewater, maintenance, plant overhead, and a return on the equipment. A cheese vat doesn't run on goodwill.

Federal milk marketing orders need a way to say, in a formula, what the plant can afford to pay farmers after those costs. Rather than guess plant by plant, the formulas use one allowance per product, applied across the order system. If you'd like the bigger picture of how those orders set minimum prices, how federal milk marketing orders work covers it.

Where the allowance sits in the formula

Here's the simplified path from a cheese price to your milk price. The formulas start with a survey-based wholesale price for the product, such as block cheese. They subtract the make allowance for that product. They then apply a yield factor, which estimates how many pounds of product come out of a pound of butterfat or protein. The result is a component price per pound, and those component prices are what feed the Class III and Class IV skim and butterfat values you see on a milk statement.

  • Product price: the wholesale commodity price used by the formula.
  • Minus make allowance: the plant's assumed cost to manufacture, per pound of product.
  • Times yield: how much product a pound of component is assumed to make.
  • Equals component value: what feeds the milk price classes.

Because the allowance is subtracted before the yield factor multiplies it, a change of even a small amount per pound gets magnified on the way to the milk price. This is why the block cheese price and the allowance together matter more than either one alone. For a refresher on the price classes the results flow into, see Class I, II, III and IV milk explained.

Who sets it and how often it changes

The allowances are written into federal order regulations, so they change only when USDA amends the orders. That means a hearing, a decision and a producer referendum, and it's not quick. USDA runs a cost-of-processing study that surveys plants to gather the data that is supposed to inform the numbers, and the agency posts information on its cost of processing page. A national pricing hearing took up make allowances along with other pieces of the formulas, and USDA keeps the record of that proceeding on its national pricing hearing page.

Between those updates, the allowance sits still while real plant costs wander around. When wages, power and freight jump, the allowance is out of date in the processor's favor to complain about. When plants get more efficient, it can be out of date in the producer's favor. Either way, a fixed number in a moving world is an invitation for a long meeting.

Why it is debated

The processor's case

Plants argue that if the allowance sits below their actual cost, they eat the difference on every pound they make. Over time, that can discourage investment in new capacity, and a region without enough plants has trouble moving milk. Processors also point out that costs have risen across the board: labor, energy, packaging and compliance.

The producer's case

Farm groups counter that the allowance is a deduction from the farm's income, and that a single number applied to every plant can reflect the costs of an average or older plant rather than the cost of a big, modern one. Where a plant makes products more cheaply than the allowance assumes, the plant keeps the gap, and where it spends more, the farm still gets the lower price. Producers also note that the survey data come from the plants themselves, so they want to know how the numbers were audited and which costs were counted.

The reasonable middle

Most of the sensible talk is about method: how often to survey, which plants to include, how to treat different plant sizes, and whether the allowance should be tied to something that updates. Honest people in dairy disagree on these, and a good dairy economist will tell you the same.

What it means for your check

You won't see a line called "make allowance" on your milk statement. Its effect is buried in the component prices and the class prices behind your blend price. Two things are worth knowing.

  • It moves cheese-country and butter-country prices the same way. The cheese, butter, powder and whey allowances each feed a different part of the formula, so a change in one can matter more to a farm with high-protein milk than to one paid mostly on fat. The butterfat vs protein article explains which components your check leans on.
  • It's one piece of the spread. A higher allowance lowers the minimum price, but your premiums, hauling charges and quality bonuses still sit on top. A plant or co-op that pays above the minimum may blunt the effect, one that pays at the minimum won't.

Don't try to calculate a precise per-hundredweight effect from a news headline. The size of the impact depends on your milk components, your order, your class mix and how your handler pays. Your handler or co-op field representative, or the market administrator for your order, can show you how a formula change plays out on your own numbers.

How to keep up without losing a weekend

  1. Read the notices your co-op sends before a hearing or referendum. They're usually the shortest summary you'll get from someone with a stake you can identify.
  2. Find your order's market administrator page, linked from USDA's Federal Milk Marketing Orders page, to see current formulas and announcements.
  3. If you get a referendum ballot, read the summary and call someone who isn't selling you anything before you mark it.
  4. Ask your handler how formula changes show up on your statement, and keep one old statement for comparison.

It's tempting to treat this as a Washington issue and leave it to the associations. But the allowance has a direct line to your milk check, and it's one of the few pricing parts that producers get to vote on. The cow doesn't care. The bank does.

Quick answers

Does a higher make allowance always mean a lower milk price?

Holding everything else the same, yes, because it's a deduction in the formulas that set minimum prices. In practice, product prices and other changes move at the same time, so you can't read the effect off a single formula change.

Is the make allowance the same for every plant?

The formula uses a single allowance per product for the order system, not each plant's own cost. Real plant costs differ by size, age, location and product mix, which is part of why the number is debated.

Can farmers vote on make allowance changes?

Amendments to federal orders go through a hearing, a decision and a producer referendum, so eligible producers and qualified cooperatives get a vote. Your co-op or market administrator can tell you how voting works for your order.

More from farm.FM Need a break from the paperwork? Farm humor and funny farm stories are always in season at farm.FM.