Dairy Hub

Milk Markets, Co-ops & Processing

How Federal Milk Marketing Orders Work

Cheese aging in a creamery and a milk tanker

A Federal Milk Marketing Order, or FMMO, is a set of USDA rules that sets the minimum price processors must pay for milk in a region, based on what the milk is used for. The money from all that milk gets pooled, and farms in the order are paid out of the pool. That pooling is why two neighbors shipping to different plants can see nearly the same base price.

If you've ever stared at a milk statement and wondered why the number has so little to do with what cheese sold for last Tuesday, the order is a big part of the answer. It stands between the market and your check.

Fair warning: this is one of those subjects where everybody at the co-op meeting has an opinion and about four people can explain it. We'll try to get you into the second group.

The milk check is the only paycheck whose formula is published in the Federal Register, and it still manages to confuse everybody.

What an order actually is

USDA's Agricultural Marketing Service describes the basics on its Federal Milk Marketing Orders page. In the language of the program, processors are called handlers and dairy farmers are called producers. A marketing area is generally a geographic region where handlers compete for packaged fluid milk sales. Each order includes a classified price plan, a system of minimum prices, the terms of the order and provisions for administering it.

The program exists to keep marketing relationships stable. Without it, a handler could pay less to one farm than another, and farms would be bargaining one at a time with a buyer that has more power than they do. The order sets a floor and a common set of rules, so everybody supplying a market area is dealing from the same sheet.

Where orders apply

The country is divided into regional orders, such as the Northeast, Upper Midwest, Appalachian, Southeast and Florida areas, among others. Not every farm in the country sells into a federal order. California, for one, has long had its own state pricing system, and several other states have state programs of various kinds. AMS keeps a map and a list of order areas on the same page, and it is worth looking up which order your milk is pooled in and who the market administrator is, since that is the office that audits the handlers and publishes the numbers.

How milk gets classified

Under an order, milk is priced by what the plant does with it. Fluid milk for drinking is one class, soft products such as ice cream, yogurt and cottage cheese are another, cheese is a third, and butter and dry milk powder are the fourth. Each class has its own minimum price formula, built from wholesale prices for the finished products, less an allowance for the cost of making them. Class I, II, III and IV milk explained goes through each one, and what a make allowance is covers that part of the formula.

The class prices are published by USDA, and AMS posts the current price formulas for each class. The formulas have been updated in recent reforms, so use the AMS page rather than an old table someone taped to the milk house wall.

Pooling: the part that surprises people

If the handler pays minimums based on class, you might expect each farm to be paid based on what its own milk became. It doesn't work that way. The order pools the value of all milk used across the marketing area. The total value of milk by class is then divided across all the hundredweights in the pool, and the result is the blended or uniform price. Handlers that use more high-value milk pay into the pool, and handlers that use less take money out of it, so the farm's pay doesn't depend on whether its truck happened to go to a bottling plant or a cheese plant.

That is the reason a farm shipping to a cheese vat can receive a blend price that includes the value of fluid milk sold in the same region. The blend price is the number most farms care about, and the pool is where it comes from.

Location also matters. Orders have differentials that give higher minimums for fluid milk in areas farther from major production regions, which is why the Southeast and Florida have historically seen strong fluid premiums. The details of how this is calculated live in the order's text, and your market administrator can explain what applies to you.

What an order does not do

  • It does not guarantee a buyer. You still need a handler or co-op to pick up your milk. See finding a milk buyer for a new dairy if you're starting out.
  • It does not set the price you actually receive. The order sets minimums for handlers. Premiums, deductions, hauling and co-op charges all land on top of or beneath the blend price.
  • It does not cap prices. Order prices follow wholesale markets, and wholesale markets move around a lot.
  • It does not cover every kind of milk sale. Some milk is exempt or sold outside the pool, and small on-farm bottlers may not be regulated the same way as large handlers.

Plan on your co-op or buyer to handle most of the compliance. The handler pays into the pool, not you, and your check already reflects the result.

How orders change

Orders aren't permanent. The Agricultural Marketing Agreement Act authorizes them, and USDA amends or establishes them through a hearing in which the industry submits proposals and evidence. Amendments only take effect after approval by producers in a referendum. In plain English, farmers get a vote, and that vote is usually organized through cooperatives, which cast votes on behalf of their members in many cases.

That means it is worth knowing what your co-op's position is before a vote, since the hearing process can move formulas by amounts that show up on your check. The way dairy cooperatives work explains how co-op bloc voting and representation function in practice.

Reading your check with an order in mind

When you read a statement, you will usually see the pounds shipped, butterfat, protein and other solids, the price paid for each component, any premiums, and the deductions. The order's minimum price shows up in the base number, and the pool settlement is built into the blend. For a line-by-line look, how to read your milk check goes through a typical statement.

If something looks wrong, ask the plant or co-op first. If you can't get a clear answer, the market administrator's office for your order handles questions about the program, and AMS lists the contacts on its site.

If the pool still feels like a magic trick, you're in good company. Even the guy who does it for a living will tell you the first rule of pooling is to read the order text twice.

Quick answers

Do all dairy farms get paid under a federal order?

No. Farms whose milk is pooled under an order get paid based on the order's minimum prices, but some states, including California, have their own systems, and some milk is sold outside of an order. Ask your buyer which order, if any, your milk is priced under.

Can my processor pay more than the order minimum?

Yes. The order sets a minimum that handlers must meet. Many buyers pay premiums for quality, volume or components, and co-ops often negotiate over-order premiums on behalf of members.

Who do I call if I think the order was applied wrong?

Start with your buyer or co-op. If you still don't have an answer, contact the market administrator for your order, whose information is on the USDA AMS site.

More from farm.FM Need a break from the paperwork? Farm humor and funny farm stories are always in season at farm.FM.