Dairy Hub

Milk Markets, Co-ops & Processing

How Block Cheese Prices Set Your Milk Price

Cheese aging in a creamery and a milk tanker

Wholesale cheese prices are one of the main inputs to the Class III milk price, and Class III in turn drives much of what farms are paid, especially in cheese country. When cheddar prices go up, the Class III formula pushes the protein and butterfat values up with it. When cheddar slumps, the check follows.

The path from a cheese block to your bank account has a few stops, though, and each one softens, delays or changes the signal. That is why a big move in the cheese market doesn't always show up as a matching jump on your statement.

Think of it as a long-distance phone call: the message gets there, but there's a delay and a little static.

The cheese market in plain terms

It's a market where a few truckloads can make headlines, which is a strange way to price a river of milk.

Cheddar is traded in two forms: 40-pound blocks and 500-pound barrels. Both are commodity products that go on to be sliced, shredded and processed. Spot trading takes place on the CME's cash market, where relatively small volumes can move the posted price. USDA's AMS also reports cheese prices through weekly surveys of manufacturers' sales, and it's these USDA numbers, rather than the daily CME quotes alone, that go into federal order price formulas. AMS Dairy Market News at ams.usda.gov carries cheese, butter and whey reports and links to the CME data.

The CME spot market is thin compared with how much cheese is made, but it is visible and quick, so people treat it as a barometer. Even when the spot price grabs the headline, the formula runs on survey data. That is one more reason your check and the daily ticker rarely match.

From cheese price to Class III

The Class III price formula starts with wholesale prices for cheese and dry whey, subtracts a make allowance that reflects the cost of turning milk into those products, and applies yield factors that estimate how much product a hundredweight of milk makes. The result is a price for the protein, the butterfat and the other solids in the milk, which are then combined into the announced Class III price at a standard test. The exact formula was updated in recent federal order reforms, so use the current documents on the AMS price formulas page. What a make allowance is breaks down the subtraction part.

In practice, higher cheese prices raise the value of protein most directly, because protein is what makes cheese. Butterfat in Class III is also affected by cheese, through its part in the formula, and by the butter market. The whey side adds some value for other solids. For the component view, see butterfat vs protein pricing.

From Class III to your check

This is where the signal gets blurry. The announced Class III price is not your pay price. Several steps sit between them:

  1. Timing. Class III is figured from product prices during the month and announced after the month ends. Your final pay follows.
  2. Pooling. In a federal order, milk of all classes is pooled and farms are paid a blend. A cheese rally lifts the Class III value in the pool, but Class I, II and IV milk are in there too. See how federal milk marketing orders work and what the blend price is.
  3. Your components and quality. Higher protein and butterfat tests get paid more, and quality premiums or penalties are applied on top.
  4. Your buyer's terms. Premiums, hauling, checkoff and co-op charges all come off or go on before the money lands. How to read your milk check shows the pieces.

The effect is that the cheese market sets the direction of the check more reliably than the exact amount.

Why a cheese rally doesn't always reach you

  • You may not ship into a cheese-driven market. A fluid-heavy order is influenced by Class III, but a smaller share of its blend comes from cheese.
  • Your co-op may smooth or hold back money. Retains, programs or pricing models can shift when you see it.
  • Costs rose too. Feed, labor and fuel don't wait for the milk check. A better price with a worse margin is still a bad month.
  • The market fell back. The spot price may be reversed before your month's pricing is final.

Regional differences

In Wisconsin, Minnesota, Idaho and other cheese-heavy regions, the Class III price and the blend usually travel in the same direction because cheese plants buy so much of the milk. The Upper Midwest milk market is a good example. In the Southeast and Florida, fluid milk is a bigger share of use, so the Class I price and its differentials carry more weight. California operates its own pricing system, with its own formulas, so the federal Class III price isn't the whole story there. If you sell on a small scale, such as farmstead cheese or a niche buyer, your price may follow a different logic entirely, and how to price farmstead cheese covers that side.

How to use this

You don't need to trade the cheese market. You do need to know that it's out there. Check weekly cheese prices when you are budgeting or negotiating, compare them with the Class III price announcements, and keep a running record of your own mailbox price so you can see how closely the two follow each other on your farm. After a few months you'll learn what a ten-cent cheese move usually does to your check, and that is a better guide than any rule of thumb in an article.

If you're considering protecting a price, bring the decision to your lender, co-op or insurance agent. Cheese-price rallies feel great right up to the moment you're asked to sign a long contract at the top.

Quick answers

Does the CME cheese price directly set the Class III price?

Not by itself. The Class III formula uses USDA survey prices for cheese and other products, adjusted by make allowances and yields. The CME spot market is a closely watched signal, and prices on the two often move together.

If cheese prices are up, why is my check flat?

Pooling, timing, your components and your buyer's deductions all sit between the cheese market and your pay. Costs may also have risen, so the margin can look flat even if the price improved.

Which dairies are most tied to cheese prices?

Farms in cheese-heavy regions like the Upper Midwest and Idaho feel it most, along with farms whose co-op prices closely off Class III. Fluid-heavy regions are affected less directly.

More from farm.FM Need a break from the paperwork? Farm humor and funny farm stories are always in season at farm.FM.