Dairy Hub

Milk Markets, Co-ops & Processing

Using Forward Contracts to Lock In a Milk Price

Cheese aging in a creamery and a milk tanker

A forward contract is an agreement, made now, to sell a set amount of milk at a set price for a future period. If the market falls, you're glad you signed. If it climbs, you're watching your neighbor's check grow while yours stays flat. That's the whole trade: you give up some upside to buy a floor under your budget.

Not every handler offers one, and the ones who do offer different versions. Some fix the whole price, some fix only the Class III or Class IV part, and some fix a basis or a premium instead. Before you sign anything, you need to know exactly which piece of the check is being locked.

Why a farm would want one

Milk prices swing a lot, as the piece on why milk prices rise and fall explains, but your feed bill, loan payment and payroll don't swing with them. A forward price lets you set a number your lender and your spouse can plan around.

It tends to fit best when:

  • You've worked out your break-even milk price and the forward price clears it with room to spare.
  • You carry a heavy payment, such as a new barn or a robot, and you need predictable months.
  • Your lender wants to see price risk managed.
  • You'd rather farm than watch a futures screen at four in the morning.

Ways to fix a price

A contract with your handler or co-op

Some processors and cooperatives offer fixed-price or price-floor programs for part of a farm's milk. The terms can be simple on paper and complicated in the fine print: which months, how many hundredweight, what happens if you ship less, and what happens if the handler's own costs move. Ask for the written terms and read them at the kitchen table, not in the truck.

Futures and options

Dairy farmers or their advisors can use Class III and Class IV contracts on the commodity exchange to set a price on the part of the check that follows those classes. The Class III futures market is worth understanding before you try this, because the futures price isn't your milk check. Your check differs by your components, your order, your premiums and your hauling, and that gap is called basis risk. Futures also involve margin calls when the market moves against you, which means cash has to be available on short notice.

Insurance-style tools

These aren't forward contracts, but they do the same job. Dairy Revenue Protection sets a revenue floor with a premium, and the federal margin program covers part of the gap between milk price and feed cost. If you're deciding between them, comparing DMC and Dairy Revenue Protection is a good place to start. USDA's Farm Service Agency describes margin coverage on its Dairy Margin Coverage page, and the Risk Management Agency lists insurance products on its main site.

What gets locked and what doesn't

This is the part that bites people. A contract that locks the Class III price leaves your butterfat and other components, your premiums and your deductions floating. A contract that locks your all-in price may cap your upside on quality premiums. Ask yourself which of these is fixed:

Piece of the checkOften fixed?What to ask
Class price or component priceSometimesWhich class and which month's price?
Premiums and quality bonusesOften notDo they still apply on top?
Hauling and promotion deductionsUsually notCan they change during the contract?
VolumeYesWhat if I ship more or less than the contract amount?

The risks nobody puts in the brochure

  • Opportunity cost. If prices rise above your locked price, you don't get the difference. That's not a loss on paper, but it feels like one when the neighbor buys a new skid steer.
  • Production shortfall. A heat wave, a feed problem or a mastitis outbreak can cut your shipments. If you promised more milk than you ship, ask what the penalty is.
  • Counterparty risk. The contract is only as good as the buyer. Ask about the handler's financial standing and how past contract holders were treated in a down market.
  • Complexity. If you can't explain the contract to your spouse or banker in two minutes, it's probably too complicated for your first one.

A sensible way to start

  1. Know your break-even and your cash needs for the next several months.
  2. Decide how much of your milk you'd be comfortable fixing. Many farms start with a modest share rather than all of it, so a bad guess doesn't sink the year's budget.
  3. Ask your handler and your lender what's available and what they'd like to see.
  4. Talk with an extension dairy economist or a risk advisor who has no product to sell. University dairy programs such as UW-Madison Dairy Extension publish market and risk-management education.
  5. Write down your reason for each contract, so that in a year you can judge the decision on its logic and not just on the outcome.

Regional differences matter. A farm in a federal order with a large Class I share, such as parts of the Southeast, may see a different kind of price movement than a farm shipping to a cheese plant in the Upper Midwest or a Western powder and cheese operation. Ask your handler how your milk is priced before you shop for protection.

Quick answers

Can any dairy farm get a forward contract?

Availability depends on your handler, co-op and region. Some buyers offer programs to all shippers and others offer none, so ask your field representative what exists and what the minimum volume is.

Is a forward contract the same as hedging with futures?

No. A forward contract is an agreement with your buyer, while futures and options are traded on an exchange and carry margin requirements. Both can fix a price, but futures leave you with basis risk and need cash on hand.

What happens if I can't ship the milk I contracted?

That depends entirely on the contract wording, so find the shortfall clause before you sign. Some agreements allow flexibility within a range, and others charge a penalty or reduce the fixed volume in later months.

More from farm.FM Need a break from the paperwork? Farm humor and funny farm stories are always in season at farm.FM.