Barns, Cow Comfort & Equipment
Sizing Manure Storage for Your Dairy Herd

A manure pit is the one piece of dairy infrastructure you can't fix by squinting at it harder. Too small, and you're hauling in the wrong weather, on frozen or saturated ground, with a neighbor taking pictures. Too big, and you've poured money into concrete or clay that sits half empty. Getting the size right takes arithmetic, local rules, and an engineer who has done it before.
This article won't give you a design number, because the correct volume depends on your cows, bedding, water use, climate, and state regulations. What it will give you is the list of what goes into the calculation, the questions to ask, and the mistakes that tend to bite later.
Start with days of storage
Storage is measured in days: how long can the system hold everything you produce before you have to empty it? The answer is driven by when you can legally and practically spread manure. In the Upper Midwest and Northeast, frozen and snow-covered ground limits winter spreading, so the storage period often needs to cover most of the cold season. In the Southeast, heavy rain and saturated soils can be the limiter. In the arid West and Southwest, crop calendars and permit conditions often drive timing more than frost.
Many states set minimum storage periods for operations above certain sizes, and some use a flat requirement while others tie it to a nutrient management plan. The range commonly runs from a few months up to six months or more, but you need your state's actual rule. Check with your state agriculture or environmental agency, your NRCS office, and your local extension office before you design anything. The federal view of animal feeding operations is outlined by the EPA animal feeding operations page, and states often run their own programs that are stricter.
What goes into the volume
People tend to think of storage volume as cows times manure. It's more than that. A realistic estimate includes:
- Manure and urine from each animal group. Lactating cows produce a lot more than dry cows, heifers, and calves, and cow size and diet change the number.
- Bedding. Sawdust, straw, sand, and recycled solids all end up in the system in different amounts. Sand adds volume and settles, which changes cleanout needs.
- Parlor and milkhouse wash water. This is a surprisingly large share on many dairies. Every pipeline wash and floor hose-down ends up in storage.
- Flush water or other process water. If you flush, the water you add is part of the load. See flush vs scraper vs robot manure systems for how each affects the volume.
- Precipitation and runoff. Rain falling on an open lagoon, runoff from lots, and milk-house roof water all count if they reach storage. Design rules usually include an allowance for a large storm event.
- Freeboard. Extra height above the maximum operating level, so a heavy rain doesn't spill over the top.
- Sludge and settled solids. The volume that sits at the bottom between cleanouts isn't available for new manure.
Add those up, apply your days of storage, and you get a design volume. An engineer or a certified planner will use standard tables and your farm's own numbers, and the farm's own numbers are better when you have them. Water meter readings, a record of how many loads you've hauled, and the actual number of animals by group all make the estimate better.
Cows come and go, and so does the volume
Don't size storage for the herd you have on a quiet day. Size it for the herd you expect to have over the life of the structure. A pit is expensive to enlarge later, and dairy herds have a habit of growing, because the bank loves a new barn. If you may add cows, heifers, or a second parlor, say so before the design is finalized. It's far cheaper to build a pit with an expansion plan than to bolt on another one.
The opposite applies too. If you plan to switch bedding, add a separator, or change from flush to scrape, volume and solids content will change. A pit built around thin liquid manure behaves differently when it fills with thicker material. The numbers on whether a manure solids separator pays are worth running before you finalize the design.
Types of storage and what they mean for size
| Type | Common use | Sizing points |
|---|---|---|
| Below-barn pit | Tiestall and freestall barns in cold regions | Fixed under the barn; volume limited by footprint and depth; gas safety is a big deal |
| Earthen basin or lagoon | Many warm and moderate regions | Needs suitable soils and liner; surface area and rainfall change volume |
| Concrete or steel tank | Wherever land or soils are limiting | Depth is controlled; often higher cost per cubic foot |
| Stacking pad or dry storage | Solid manure, bedded packs | Needs runoff control; sized by solids volume and stacking height |
Each of these has its own permit and design standard. In many places, NRCS practice standards for waste storage facilities provide the technical backbone, and your local NRCS office can tell you which standard applies and whether cost-share funding is available. The NRCS animal management resources are a sensible place to start.
Regulatory basics to check early
- Does your herd size trigger a permit? Larger operations are often regulated as concentrated animal feeding operations, and smaller ones may be covered by state rules instead. The line moves depending on the state and on how manure leaves the farm.
- Is a nutrient management plan required? Many states require one, and it ties storage capacity to how much land you have for spreading.
- Setbacks. Distances from wells, streams, property lines, and neighbors can restrict where a pit or lagoon can go.
- Design approval. Some states require a licensed engineer or an approved plan before construction. Construction without it can mean redoing the work.
- Inspection and recordkeeping. Expect to record levels, freeboard, and spreading events.
Rules differ widely, so don't take any generalization, including this one, as the final word. Ask your state agency, then ask your neighbor who built a pit recently and complained about the paperwork, then ask the agency again if the two answers don't match.
Safety and management during design
Storage design is also a safety decision. Agitation points, access hatches, ventilation, and fencing all depend on the layout. Pits under barns can release dangerous gases when agitated, and your crew needs a clear routine. Read manure pit gas safety for dairy crews before anyone stirs anything. A good designer will plan agitation, pump-out locations, and access so that nobody has to climb into a pit for routine work.
Mistakes that cost money
- Sizing for the current herd and ignoring growth.
- Leaving out wash water, which can be a big, steady contributor.
- Forgetting that rainfall on a lagoon counts as volume, and that a wet spring doesn't care about your plan.
- Not asking whether your spreading land and timing match the storage period. A pit that holds six months of manure doesn't help if you can only spread for two weeks a year.
- Skipping the conversation with the engineer until the contractor is already there with the excavator and a bill by the hour.
A pit is a lot like a feed bunk: there's never quite enough room right when you need it most. Sizing it carefully is dull work, but dull work beats an emergency pump-out in a rainstorm.
Quick answers
How many days of manure storage do I need?
It depends on your state rules, climate, and when you can spread. Many operations need several months of storage, and some regions require six months or more. Your state agency or nutrient management planner can give you the number that applies.
How much manure does a dairy cow produce?
It varies with cow size, milk production, diet, and group, and standard design tables give figures by animal type. Use those tables or your engineer's numbers, then add bedding, wash water, and rainfall, which often add up to more than people expect.
Can I use NRCS programs to help pay for storage?
Cost-share programs may be available, and requirements and funding vary by state and by program. Contact your local NRCS office early, since planning and approval usually need to happen before construction starts.