Dairy Hub

Barns, Cow Comfort & Equipment

Is a Manure Solids Separator Worth the Cost?

Holstein cow in a robotic milking stall

A solids separator does one simple job: it squeezes or screens the thick stuff out of liquid manure so you end up with two products instead of one. That sounds tidy. Whether it's worth buying depends on what you do with each product, and that's where the numbers either work or don't.

The honest answer is that a separator pays on some dairies and sits as an expensive piece of rust on others. It tends to pay where the solids have a real job, such as replacing purchased bedding, cutting the volume of what goes into storage, or making the pit easier to agitate and pump. It tends not to pay where the solids just become one more pile to haul. Work out the job first, then the price.

What a separator actually does

Separators come in a few common types. A screw press pushes manure against a screen and squeezes the water out. A roller press does something similar with rollers. Inclined screens let liquid run through while solids slide off the end. Gravity settling basins and sand traps are slower, lower-tech ways to pull out heavy solids. Each type leaves you with a solids stream of a different dryness, and different handling needs.

What you get out of any of them isn't pure. The liquid side still carries nutrients and fine particles, and the solid side is wet. How dry the solids come out depends on the machine, the manure, the feed, how much water you flush with, and how it's running that day. That's why visiting a working farm with a similar setup is worth more than any brochure.

Where the savings come from

Bedding

This is the big one for many freestall dairies. Separated solids that are dried or composted can be used as stall bedding. That swaps a purchased product like sawdust, shavings, or straw for something you make yourself, and when bedding prices jump, that matters. How well it works depends on your management and your mastitis control, which is a topic of its own. The article on recycling manure solids as freestall bedding covers how it's done and what to watch for.

Storage and handling

Pulling solids out of the stream can reduce the amount that builds up in a pit or lagoon, and it can make the liquid easier to pump, agitate, and spread through irrigation or tanker. Less buildup of solids means longer intervals between cleanouts. It doesn't make the nutrients disappear, because they're still there in two forms, but it makes storage and application easier to manage. If you're sizing a new system, run the numbers with and without a separator, as covered in sizing manure storage for your dairy herd.

Sand-laden systems

Farms using sand bedding often need sand separation in some form to keep the sand from settling in pits and pipes. That's a different job from a standard solids separator, and the equipment, sizing, and wear are specific. If sand is your plan, see sand versus mattress stalls for how that choice flows through the rest of the barn.

Odor and handling

Some farms report that separating changes the odor and handling character of what's stored. That can matter if you have neighbors close by. Results vary, and it isn't a guaranteed fix.

Where the costs come from

  • Purchase and installation. The machine, the pad, the pump, the pipes, the conveyor or auger, and the electrical service. People tend to budget for the machine and forget the rest.
  • Power. Motors and pumps run for hours every day.
  • Wear parts. Screens, augers, rollers, and bearings wear, especially with sand or fibrous material in the stream.
  • Labor. Someone has to check it, clear jams, move the solids, and keep the area clean. Machines never jam on a quiet Tuesday.
  • Handling the product. Space for stacking, drying, or composting; equipment to load and haul it.
  • Management of the bedding use. If you use the solids for bedding, add the cost of testing, extra attention to stall maintenance, and the cost of a mastitis control program that stays tight.

A simple way to run your own numbers

  1. Find your current bedding cost per cow per day, including delivery, storage, and handling. Use your own records, not what the neighbor says he pays.
  2. Estimate how much bedding the solids could actually replace. Ask farms with similar barns and ask the dealer for references, not for a promise. The answer depends on dryness and how you use them.
  3. Add up the annual cost of ownership: loan payment, power, repairs, labor, and an allowance for wear parts.
  4. Add or subtract handling effects: cleanout savings, lower pumping or hauling cost, or the added cost of hauling extra product.
  5. Compare the savings and the costs, then stress-test it. What if bedding prices fall? What if mastitis rises and you have to go back to purchased bedding? What if you add cows?

The dairy farm budget template can help you lay those numbers out, and a conversation with your lender and an extension specialist will keep the rosy assumptions in check.

Who it suits and who it doesn't

SituationLikely fit
Freestall herd buying a lot of bedding, with a plan to use recycled solidsOften worth a serious look
Herd on sand with sand-laden manureSand separation is usually part of the system design, not an optional add-on
Tiestall barn with a gutter cleaner and small herdRarely a fit; the scale and layout don't support it
Large flush system moving a lot of waterOften considered, since solids removal can help downstream storage
Dairy with no use for the solids and no place to put themProbably not, unless a storage or regulatory benefit outweighs the cost

If you flush, the system shape matters a lot, so check flush, scraper and robot manure systems before you decide where a separator would sit in the flow.

Regulatory and nutrient angles

A separator changes where the nutrients are, which changes your nutrient management plan. The liquid and solid streams carry different concentrations, and the spreading plan has to reflect that. Check with your state agency and your planner before you assume the permit paperwork stays the same. If you plan to sell or give away solids as a soil amendment, local rules may apply. Extension can help you sort out what applies where, and the UW-Madison Dairy extension articles are a good source for current dairy housing and manure management thinking.

What to ask the dealer

  • Can I visit three working farms with my bedding and my kind of manure?
  • What dryness do the solids typically reach in those operations, and what do they do with them?
  • Which parts wear out first, and what do they cost?
  • What's the service response time?
  • What happens to performance in a hard freeze?

The best separator is the one that has a clear job in your system. Buy it for the job, not because the neighbor has a shiny one next to his barn and has taken to standing near it.

Quick answers

How much can a separator save on bedding?

It depends on how dry the solids get, how you process them, and how much of your bedding they can really replace. Ask for references from farms with similar barns and run your own numbers from your own bedding records.

Is recycled manure solids bedding safe for cows?

It can work on well-managed dairies, but it raises mastitis management questions, especially around bedding quality and stall upkeep. Work through the plan with your herd vet and milk quality advisor before switching.

Does a separator reduce manure storage needs?

It can reduce solids buildup and make pumping easier, and some designs allow smaller or more flexible storage. It doesn't eliminate storage, and the nutrients still need a plan. Have an engineer include the separator in the design.

More from farm.FM Need a break from the paperwork? Farm humor and funny farm stories are always in season at farm.FM.