Dairy Hub

Grazing, Organic & Small Dairies

Sheep Milk for Cheese: The Economics for Small Farms

Jersey cows grazing in clover pasture

Anyone who says sheep milk makes easy money has either never lambed a flock at three in the morning or is selling ewes. The price per pound is high, the cheese is excellent, and the spreadsheet still has plenty of ways to go sideways.

Here's the short version. Sheep milk is rich, so it makes more cheese per hundredweight than cow milk. It sells for several times the cow milk price, but you get far less of it per animal and for a shorter season. Whether that works for you depends on what you spend on parlor, labor and freezer space, and whether you sell milk to a cheesemaker or make the cheese yourself.

Why sheep milk is worth more

It comes down to solids. Dairy ewe milk typically carries fat in the 6 to 8 percent range and protein around 5 to 7 percent, according to University of Wisconsin extension material on dairy sheep. A cheesemaker gets noticeably more curd out of a vat of sheep milk than out of the same volume of cow milk, which is why the price per hundredweight is so much higher. Most milk checks for sheep are also adjusted for fat, protein and somatic cell count, just as cow milk is, so quality counts here as much as anywhere.

The US has long imported big volumes of sheep milk cheeses such as Roquefort, Manchego and Pecorino Romano, so domestic demand for the real thing has been there for a long time. The catch: not many cheesemakers use sheep milk, and the ones who do are rarely down the road.

The volume problem

A dairy-breed ewe gives a few hundred pounds of milk a lactation, and strong dairy genetics can push that higher. A crossbred ewe gives less, and an ordinary meat ewe gives very little. Lactations run months, not the better part of a year, and ewes dry off as days shorten in fall. If you want the numbers by breed and lambing system, the dairy sheep basics piece has a table, and the University of Wisconsin guide to raising dairy sheep has more detail on lambing systems and feed.

Per animal, that is a small number next to a cow. The economics only work because each pound earns a lot, so the farm has to keep costs per pound low: cheap forage, tight lambing, healthy udders, and a milk room you aren't paying off for twenty years.

Seasonality, and what to do with it

Sheep milk comes in a wave, not a stream. Winter lambing gives the longest lactation but needs more stored feed and good lambing space. Spring lambing is cheaper but shorter. You can't milk sheep year-round with one group, though a farm with two groups lambing in different seasons can spread the equipment over more ewes a year.

Many producers handle the wave by freezing milk on the farm. Frozen milk can be held for the cheesemaker and shipped in a climate-controlled truck, which means the farm doesn't have to be next door to the plant. The part people miss is that freezing needs real equipment: a household chest freezer is too slow, and extension guidance describes walk-in freezers with substantial compressor capacity. Put that on the budget line before the ewes.

Where the money comes from, and goes

On an extension-style budget for a dairy sheep operation, milk is usually the main revenue source, often more than half of farm income, with lambs second and wool a minor line. Wool is not going to save you.

Budget lineWhat to watch
Milk salesPrice depends on buyer, components, and somatic cell count
Lamb salesSlower growth if lambs nurse a month; replacer cost if raised on bottles
FeedPasture trims it; lactating ewes need good protein and plenty of water
LaborLambing, bottle lambs and twice-a-day milking add up fast
Parlor and milk roomOne of the largest expenses; inspect before you build
Freezer or tankNeeded to hold milk between pickups
Vet and healthMastitis checks, vaccines, parasite control; work with your veterinarian

Lamb handling changes the math more than most newcomers expect. If lambs are pulled early and raised on milk replacer, every drop of ewe milk is sold, but labor and replacer cost go up. If lambs nurse for a month, labor drops and so does the milk you sell. Neither is wrong. It depends on whether your constraint is time or money, and on most small farms it's both.

Sell the milk or make the cheese?

Selling milk to a cheesemaker means no plant license of your own, no aging space and no marketing, but you take the price you're offered, and a single buyer has a lot of leverage. Making the cheese yourself can capture much more value per pound of milk. It also means a licensed plant, aging space, labels and sales work, which is a different business sitting next to a sheep dairy.

If you're leaning that way, start with the farmstead creamery startup checklist and what to expect when licensing a dairy plant, then work out pricing with how to price farmstead cheese. Raw milk cheese, pasteurized cheese and aged cheese all face different rules, and those vary by state and product, so your state dairy agency is the real authority.

A cheap sanity check

Before buying anything, write down the number of ewes you could actually milk (figure on roughly 85 to 90 percent of the ones you breed), a conservative yield per ewe, and a price you have in writing from a buyer. Then subtract feed, labor you'd otherwise pay for, and equipment payments. If the profit only appears when every number is optimistic, treat that as a no.

Common ways this goes wrong

  • No buyer lined up. A freezer full of milk is a very expensive freezer.
  • Counting every ewe as a milker. Some won't breed, lamb or stay free of udder trouble.
  • Ignoring quality. Cell count and bacteria can cut the price or lose the contract.
  • Underpricing your own labor. A farm that pays nobody for the early mornings is a hobby with a tax number.
  • Skipping a trial. Milk a small group for a season and see what the paperwork and the ewes really do.

For producer-to-producer help, the Dairy Sheep Association of North America connects growers, processors and researchers, and its members have already made most of the mistakes worth avoiding. For goats, the same logic applies, and finding buyers for goat milk covers the buyer question from that side.

Quick answers

How much is sheep milk worth?

Typically several times the price of cow milk per hundredweight, but it varies by buyer, milk components and quality, and there are few buyers. Ask any prospective buyer for a written price schedule before you commit.

Can I freeze sheep milk for cheese?

Many producers do, and cheesemakers accept frozen milk from sheep dairies. Freezing needs a freezer that can pull heat out of the milk quickly, so check with your buyer on handling and with your state regulator on licensing.

Do I need a license to sell sheep milk?

Almost always. Selling milk or cheese generally requires a producer or plant license through your state dairy agency, and the requirements differ depending on whether the milk is fluid, frozen or going into cheese. Call before you build anything.

More from farm.FM Need a break from the paperwork? Farm humor and funny farm stories are always in season at farm.FM.