Dairy Hub

Milking & Milk Quality

What a High PI Count Says About Your Cleaning

Milk sample and modern dairy parlor

A high preliminary incubation count, or PI, usually means bacteria are getting into your milk from somewhere other than a healthy udder: from the milking system, the bulk tank, dirty teats or slow cooling. Of all the bacteria numbers on your milk report, it is the one that most often points at cleaning.

The test is simple in concept. The lab holds a milk sample at a cool temperature for a set time, which lets cold-loving bacteria multiply, and then counts what grew. It is, in effect, a preview of what would happen to your milk if it sat in a refrigerator for a while with the wrong bugs on board.

Nobody enjoys finding out that the lab grew a small bacterial garden out of their milk. Better to know than not, because the PI count is one of the most useful pieces of paper in the milk house.

How the test works

As Penn State Extension explains in its article on using bacterial counts to troubleshoot problems, the lab incubates the milk sample at 55°F for 18 hours so that psychrotrophs, bacteria that grow at refrigeration temperatures, can multiply. Then it runs a standard plate count on the incubated sample. Many of these bacteria are Gram-negative and thrive in milk that is held cold but not cold enough, or that was contaminated in the first place.

A short extension newsletter from Virginia Tech, an archived Dairy Pipeline piece on PI counts, describes the same method and adds a useful point: these cold-tolerant bacteria produce enzymes that can damage milk protein and fat, and some of those enzymes can survive pasteurization. That is why processors care.

One caution from the Penn State article: a study found PI count does not reliably predict the shelf life of pasteurized milk. So think of it mainly as a management indicator for your farm, not a guarantee of how the finished product will perform.

Reading PI next to SPC

A PI number by itself is only half the story. Compare it with the standard plate count on the same sample.

  • PI much higher than SPC: Penn State notes this points to contamination coming from outside the udder, such as the environment or the milking system.
  • High PI with low SPC: the Virginia Tech newsletter suggests a pipeline or tank cleaning problem, a refrigeration problem, or poor udder cleaning.
  • High PI and high SPC together: this combination could point to a mastitis problem, which you can check by looking at herd and individual cow SCC.

The PI will generally come out higher than the SPC on the same milk, so don't panic at the first sight of a larger number. What you want to watch is how large the gap is and whether it trends in the wrong direction.

What usually causes a high PI

Penn State cites research linking higher PI counts to inadequate teat preparation, poor bulk tank cleaning and the choice of a specific detergent. The other usual suspects:

  • Biofilm or milkstone in the pipeline, receiver or tank.
  • Worn liners and rubber that can't be cleaned properly.
  • Hard water that weakens detergent and sanitizer.
  • Slow cooling or milk sitting in lines that don't drain.
  • Dirty udders from wet bedding or muddy lots.

A fix-it order that makes sense

Step one: confirm the wash

Measure the wash water at the start and end of the cycle and check the detergent mix against the label. If the water cools too much or the mix is off, the system will never get fully clean. The wash water temperature and chemical strength guide is a good place to calibrate.

Step two: inspect the tank and its small parts

Pull the outlet valve, gaskets and agitator parts and look at them closely. A consistent bulk tank cleaning routine that includes these small parts is a common fix.

Step three: check cooling and draining

Verify the milk is down to 45°F within two hours of finishing milking, as covered under bulk tank cooling requirements, and check that lines drain without pooling milk.

Step four: look at prep and rubber

Watch teat prep for a full milking. Check contact time with the dip and the cleanliness of the towels. Then inspect the liners and hoses for cracks and wear.

Step five: broaden the search

If all that checks out and the count stays up, work through the full bacteria count troubleshooting checklist, including water supply testing and mastitis screening.

Keep a log

PI counts bounce around, and a single high result is not an emergency. A log works better than memory. Write down each result with the date, what changed in the barn that week, and what you did about it. After a few months, patterns appear: the heat wave that always raises counts, the detergent that did not work, the new milker who skipped a step, the water heater that fails when the temperature drops.

It also helps to ask your milk plant fieldman how PI counts are reported and what the plant considers a good target, since goals differ by buyer and region. Plants differ in how often they run PI and whether it feeds into a premium program.

The most reliable place to find a stubborn PI problem is wherever you assume you have already checked. Pull that one apart again.

Quick answers

What does PI count stand for?

Preliminary incubation count. The lab holds the milk sample cool for about 18 hours before plating it, so cold-tolerant bacteria have time to multiply and show up.

Is a high PI count a sign of mastitis?

Not usually on its own. A PI far above the SPC points more to the environment or milking system, though high PI and high SPC together can signal a mastitis issue, so check SCC as well.

What is the quickest thing to fix when PI goes up?

Check the wash temperature and chemical mix, then the bulk tank's outlet valve and gaskets. Both checks are quick and cost nothing but time, which makes them the right place to start before you spend money on parts.

More from farm.FM Need a break from the paperwork? Farm humor and funny farm stories are always in season at farm.FM.