Dairy Hub

Nutrition, Feed & Forage

Testing Dairy Water for Nitrates and Sulfur

Mixer wagon feeding dairy cows

Wells don't send reminders. A water supply that was fine when the dairy was built can drift for years, with a nearby field changing nitrate levels, a dry spell concentrating sulfates, or a cracked casing letting in bacteria. The cows won't file a complaint. They'll just drink a little less, milk a little less, and leave you to blame the ration.

A water test costs about what a bag of mineral does, and it answers a question no amount of staring at the trough can. Test the water you give cows, test it at the tap they actually drink from, and retest on a schedule. This is general education, so take unusual results to your herd veterinarian, nutritionist or extension specialist for interpretation.

What to test for

Package names vary by lab, but a livestock water panel usually covers several things.

Nitrate

Nitrate in water comes mostly from fertilizer, manure, septic systems and sometimes shallow or poorly sealed wells. In cattle, high nitrate intake can reduce the blood's ability to carry oxygen, and the problem stacks with nitrate in feed. That matters most after a drought or other crop stress, when forages can carry elevated nitrate. Cattle and human thresholds differ, and labs report results in two different ways, as nitrate or as nitrate-nitrogen, so read the units on the report. For reference, the federal drinking water limit for people is expressed as nitrate-nitrogen, and the EPA's drinking water regulations page lists it. Cattle guidance is different, so ask your nutritionist what the number means for your herd.

Sulfate and sulfur

Sulfur from water adds to sulfur from feed. High total sulfur can interfere with copper and other minerals, and in extreme cases contribute to serious neurological disease in cattle. Water with a rotten-egg smell or taste is a hint, but not every high-sulfate water smells, and a lab test is the only way to know. Distillers grains and some other byproducts carry sulfur too, which is why the water and the ration have to be looked at together. See byproduct feeds for dairy cows for more on that side.

Bacteria

Coliform and total bacterial counts show whether surface water, manure or a failing well seal is getting in. Heavy contamination hurts intake and can contribute to herd health problems. Bacteria testing also matters for the milking system, since water is used in the parlor and for cleaning.

Total dissolved solids, hardness, pH, sodium, iron

High salts or total dissolved solids can reduce water intake and cause loose manure. Hardness and iron mostly matter for equipment and cleaning, which is a bigger deal in some regions than others. Hard water and dairy cleaning in the Mountain West covers that angle.

How to collect a sample

  1. Call the lab first. Ask for their livestock or farm water package, the container to use, and how fast the sample must arrive. Bacteria samples usually need sterile bottles and quick delivery.
  2. Sample where cows drink. A tap at the barn, a trough, and the well head can show different things. Collect from the troughs cows use and, if you suspect the supply, from the source as well.
  3. Let the water run first, unless the lab tells you otherwise, so you're not sampling what's been sitting in the pipe.
  4. Avoid contamination. Don't touch the inside of the bottle or cap. Skip the hose end if it's been lying in the manure.
  5. Keep it cool and ship quickly. A sample that rides in a hot truck for two days tells the lab about your truck.
  6. Label everything. Date, location, source, and what you want tested.

Using the lab's own bottle matters. A repurposed jug from the shop that once held something else gives you data about the jug.

Where to send it

State agriculture labs, land-grant universities, commercial ag labs and county health or extension offices can all help. Your feed or forage lab may do water too. A call to your local extension office is a fast way to find the right lab and learn what results usually mean in your area. Programs such as University of Minnesota Extension dairy publish water-quality guidance for livestock, and most state extension sites do something similar.

Reading the results

Reports often show numbers without telling you what they mean for a milking cow. A few habits help:

  • Check units. Nitrate versus nitrate-nitrogen, milligrams per liter versus parts per million. Confusing them can make a mild result look dangerous or a risky one look fine.
  • Count the whole diet. Nitrate and sulfur in feed and water add together. A moderate number in each can add up to a problem.
  • Think about the cow. Fresh and high-producing cows drink the most, so they get the biggest dose. A pen of dry cows in a field may be exposed to less.
  • Compare to last time. Trends tell more than one result. A slow climb tells you to act before the number becomes a problem.
  • Bring in the pros. Your vet and nutritionist can read the report against the ration and the herd's symptoms.

If you also feed mineral free-choice, the interaction with sulfur and copper is worth discussing with your nutritionist. Dairy mineral program basics is a reasonable starting point.

When to test and retest

  • When you first take over a farm or drill a new well
  • At least on a regular schedule, such as once a year for the basics, more often if problems appear
  • After a flood, heavy rain, nearby construction or any change at the well
  • During and after drought, when concentrations can rise, and see feeding dairy cows during drought for the feed side of the same year
  • When milk, intake or herd health slips and nothing else explains it
  • Whenever you add a high-sulfur feed to the ration

If the results are bad

Don't panic and don't improvise. Options may include a different water source, dilution with better water, treatment equipment, well repair or rebuilding the seal, and ration changes to offset the load. The right choice depends on the problem, the size of the herd and the budget. Meanwhile, avoid assuming that adding a mineral will cover a water issue. The fix for a nitrate problem and the fix for a sulfur problem are different.

If a number looks alarming, retest before acting, and while you wait, ask your vet whether the herd should be on another source. And yes, the cows will still demand the same trough, whatever the report says. They have opinions about change.

Finally, remember the rest of the water system. A perfect lab report doesn't help if the trough is slimy or the flow is slow. Setting up waterers for a dairy barn and water needs of dairy cows cover that part.

Quick answers

How often should I test my dairy well?

Many farms test the basics yearly and retest after any change, such as flooding, drought or a repair. If cows or production look off with no clear cause, test sooner.

Can I smell high sulfur in water?

Sometimes, because sulfur water often smells like rotten eggs, but a lack of smell doesn't mean a lack of sulfate. Only a lab test tells you the level.

Is water that's safe for people safe for cows?

Not always. Standards and risks differ, and a cow drinking many gallons a day on a high-sulfur or high-nitrate diet may be affected at levels people tolerate. Ask your vet or nutritionist to interpret the numbers for your herd.

More from farm.FM Need a break from the paperwork? Farm humor and funny farm stories are always in season at farm.FM.