Dairy Hub

Nutrition, Feed & Forage

Calculating Feed Cost per Hundredweight of Milk

Mixer wagon feeding dairy cows

Feed cost per hundredweight of milk is one division problem: what you spent feeding the cows, divided by how much milk they shipped, in hundredweights. Income over feed cost is the milk check minus that feed bill. Those two numbers tell you more about a month on the dairy than the bank balance does, and they take about fifteen minutes to figure once you have the inputs.

The trouble isn't the arithmetic. It's the inputs. Most farms have the milk numbers sitting on the milk statement and the feed numbers scattered across three co-op invoices, a pile of home-grown forage nobody priced, and a notebook in the truck. Pull those together once and the rest is easy.

The basic formulas

A hundredweight, or cwt, is 100 pounds of milk. A gallon of milk weighs a little over 8.5 pounds, so a cwt is somewhere around 11 or 12 gallons. You'll see feed cost expressed either way, but cwt is what milk prices and most benchmarks use.

  1. Feed cost per cow per day = total feed cost for the group divided by cow-days fed.
  2. Milk per cow per day in cwt = pounds of milk shipped divided by cow-days, divided by 100.
  3. Feed cost per cwt = feed cost per cow per day divided by milk per cow per day in cwt.
  4. Income over feed cost (IOFC) per cow per day = milk income per cow per day minus feed cost per cow per day.

Use cows in the milking string for the milk side. Whether dry cows and heifers belong in the feed side depends on what question you're asking, and you should pick one approach and stick with it so your month-to-month comparisons mean something.

A worked example

These are round, made-up numbers chosen to make the arithmetic easy. Swap in your own.

ItemExample
Milk per cow per day70 lb (0.70 cwt)
Feed cost per cow per day$7.50
Feed cost per cwt$7.50 / 0.70 = about $10.71
Milk price (example)$20.00 per cwt
Milk income per cow per day0.70 x $20.00 = $14.00
Income over feed cost$14.00 - $7.50 = $6.50 per cow per day

Now try a cheaper ration. Say you trim feed cost to $7.00 a day but milk slips to 66 pounds. Feed cost per cwt becomes $7.00 / 0.66, about $10.61, which looks like a win. But milk income falls to $13.20, so IOFC is $6.20, which is lower than before. The feed bill went down and the farm got poorer. That is exactly why the per-cwt figure alone can fool you, and why IOFC is the number to watch.

Gathering the inputs

Purchased feed

Add up invoices for the period: grain mix, protein, minerals, buffers, byproducts, freight. Don't forget the small stuff. A mineral premix and a few tons of this and that can be a surprising slice of the total when you finally write it down.

Home-raised feed

This is where people cheat themselves. Corn silage and haylage have a cost even when you grew them: seed, fertilizer, fuel, labor, equipment, storage and shrink. Many farms value home-raised forage at what it would cost to buy, or at cost of production, or at an agreed market price. Any of those works if you use it consistently. Using zero does not, and the milk check will happily make you look like a genius until the cropping year turns bad.

Cow counts and milk

Use the milk shipped, from the milk statement or bulk tank pickup records, and the number of cows milking each day. Keep an eye on milk dumped, discarded for treatments or fed to calves, since it was produced but not sold. Your record keeping system should make these numbers easy to pull, not a scavenger hunt.

Reading the result

Feed costs and milk prices change, so there's no single right number. A few ways to put yours in context:

  • Trend it. Your own numbers month to month are the most useful comparison you have.
  • Compare by group. A fresh pen with high IOFC and a late-lactation pen with low IOFC is normal. A mid-lactation pen with falling IOFC is worth investigating.
  • Compare to peers. Many extension programs and dairy benchmarking groups publish feed cost and IOFC figures. The UW-Madison dairy extension site is a good starting point, and USDA's Economic Research Service dairy pages carry national cost and return data.

Also check what the milk price represents. Milk checks include components, premiums, deductions and hauling charges that vary by handler and federal order. Use net price per cwt actually received if you can, and be consistent.

Common mistakes

  • Leaving out home-raised feed, or valuing it at zero.
  • Counting dry cows in the denominator one month and not the next.
  • Using the ration the software says you fed instead of the feed you purchased and loaded.
  • Ignoring shrink. Feed you bought and lost still hit the bill.
  • Chasing the lowest feed cost per cwt instead of the highest IOFC.
  • Measuring once, then never again. One reading is a snapshot. Three months is a pattern.

If the ration report and the reality don't match, reading the dairy ration report carefully will often explain it, and how much dry matter a cow actually eats is the usual suspect. Cows are famously poor at following software.

What to do with the number

Once you have a baseline, the interesting questions follow. Is a pen eating more than the ration assumes? Is the price of a single ingredient driving the whole bill? Is shrink bigger than you thought? Cutting feed cost without losing milk picks up from there, and in a tight year the low milk price playbook shows where the next dollars come from. Neither works without a number to start from.

A last practical tip: put this on the calendar. First of the month, same chair, same coffee. The farms that watch IOFC aren't smarter than the ones that don't. They just look at it before the lender does.

Quick answers

What is a good feed cost per cwt?

There's no universal target because milk price, region and herd type all matter. Compare against your own history and against benchmarks from extension or your dairy lender, and watch income over feed cost alongside it.

Should I count dry cows and heifers in feed cost?

For milking-herd IOFC, many farms use only lactating cows. For whole-farm cost, include dry cows and replacements. Pick one method and keep using it so the trends mean something.

How often should I calculate it?

Monthly is a good rhythm, and by pen if you can manage it. Calculate again whenever you change the ration or a major ingredient price shifts.

More from farm.FM Need a break from the paperwork? Farm humor and funny farm stories are always in season at farm.FM.