How to Sample Forage for a Lab Analysis

A forage test is only as good as the handful of feed that goes in the bag. The lab can measure that handful to a decimal point, but it cannot tell whether your handful looks like the other forty tons. University of Wisconsin forage specialists put it bluntly in their sampling publication: the largest error in forage analysis is improper sampling on the farm.
The good news is that sampling right is not hard. It takes a probe, a clean pail, a freezer, and about fifteen minutes of discipline. Skip that and you will be balancing rations on numbers that describe a bale you did not feed.
The steps are a little different for hay, haylage, and silage, and for sampling at harvest versus at feeding. Here is how to do each, and how to avoid the mistakes that make test results useless.
First, define the lot
A lot is the unit you test. For hay or silage, the University of Wisconsin publication defines it as forage harvested within a day from one field, from the same cutting, at the same stage of maturity, and visually uniform. Different cutting, different field, different day, or a rain-damaged stretch all mean a different lot. Test each lot separately.
That means you need to keep track. Mark where each lot is stacked, note the number of bales or the location in the bunker, and write it down while you still remember. Nothing is as useless as a great forage test for a lot nobody can find.
Sampling hay
A hay bale is not uniform. Leaves and stems settle in different parts, and a bale that looks even on the outside may not be even inside. That is why a core sampler beats a handful pulled from the outside of a bale.
- Use a hay probe. The Wisconsin publication recommends a core sampler with an internal diameter of at least 3/8 inch and a length of 12 to 18 inches, with a sharp tip so it cuts through stems instead of pushing them aside. Many extension offices lend them out, so call yours.
- Take 15 to 20 cores per lot. Both Wisconsin and Alabama Extension give that range. More cores mean less sampling error, and the Wisconsin figures show the spread of results shrinking considerably between a few cores and 20.
- Core the right spot. For small rectangular bales, go into the center of the end of the bale. For round bales, probe into the curved side. Go in at a right angle.
- Spread your samples around. Sample bales from different parts of the stack, not the five closest to the door.
- Mix the cores in a clean pail. Put the whole sample in a sealed bag. Do not divide it. Leaves and stems may separate and settle in the bag, which is normal.
- Label it. Your name, sample number, forage type, and the lot location.
Sampling haylage and silage
At harvest
Sampling at harvest is the easiest way to get a representative sample, and it tells you early what you have to plan for. The Wisconsin guidance for chopped forage suggests collecting several handfuls from the middle of the load as the wagon unloads, putting them in a bag, and refrigerating or freezing right away. Repeat over several loads through the day, combine, mix well, and label by field. Do this for every field harvested that day.
From a bunker, pile, or bag at feeding
- Do not sample the spoiled material on top or at the surface.
- If you feed a TMR, one approach is to load the silage into the mixer, mix well, and take several grab samples to build a total sample of a pound or two.
- If you do not feed a TMR, collect from different vertical layers of the freshly exposed face, after the day's feeding has been removed, again to a total of a pound or two.
- For forage that was ensiled too wet or too dry, or when seepage or heating occurred, resample at feeding, since fiber and protein values can shift.
- Recheck dry matter at feeding. Fiber and protein usually hold steady in a properly fermented silage, but moisture can change.
From a tower silo
Take samples from the unloader while it is running, from both morning and evening feedings on the same day, mix them, and bag the whole sample.
For specifics on baleage, wrapped haylage, and high-moisture crops, Alabama Extension's collecting forage samples for laboratory analysis lists the steps for each type.
Handling and shipping
A sample left on the dash of a pickup in July is no longer a sample, it is a science fair project.
- Seal the sample in a clean bag, squeeze out the air, and keep it cool.
- Freeze wet samples right away if you cannot ship the same day. Silage keeps fermenting and heating in a warm bag, and a warm bag ruins the result.
- Ship early in the week so the sample does not sit in a mail room over a weekend.
- Fill out the lab form. Say what the forage is, what you want tested, and how you plan to use the numbers. Ask whether your lab uses near-infrared testing, and which package they recommend for dairy forage.
- Keep a copy of the sheet with your lot map so you can find the right feed later.
Mistakes that wreck a sample
- Grabbing a handful off the top of the pile, because it is the easiest.
- Sampling the best-looking bale, or the worst one.
- Mixing different lots into one bag and calling it an average.
- Letting wet samples sit in a hot truck.
- Sampling the spoiled surface of a bunker.
- Waiting until the feed is half gone, and finding out the first half was different.
The person who brags that they have sampled forage for twenty years with the same handful from the same corner has been very consistent and possibly very wrong.
Using the results
Once the report comes back, the numbers belong in the ration. Share the results with your nutritionist right away, because forage that tests differently than assumed changes what the cows need on top of it. Reading a forage test: RFV, RFQ, NDF and beyond explains the common numbers, and forage inventory shows how to match lots to what you will need. If a lot looks off, the cause may be in the field or the pile, such as silage heating at the face.
Sampling plus testing costs very little compared with the feed it protects. Many dairies sample every new lot, resample when feeding conditions change, and keep a record of results over seasons to spot patterns.
For the full University of Wisconsin publication, see Sampling Hay and Silage for Analysis.
Quick answers
How many samples do I need for a hay test?
Extension guidance calls for 15 to 20 cores from each lot, combined into one sample. Fewer cores mean a bigger chance that the result misses the true value of the lot.
Can I sample silage from the top of the pile?
No. The surface is often spoiled and does not represent what the cows eat. Remove spoiled material first and sample from the freshly exposed face, or sample at harvest.
How often should I test forage?
Test each new lot, and retest when the feed changes in moisture, quality, or storage conditions. Many dairies also recheck dry matter often, since moisture can change from week to week.