Dairy Hub

Calves & Replacement Heifers

Nesting Scores: Is Your Calf Bedding Deep Enough

Bottle-feeding a Holstein calf

Walk past the hutches on a cold morning and look at the calves that are lying down. If you can see all four legs stretched out on top of the bedding, that calf is lying on a cold floor with a little straw underneath it. If you can't see her legs at all, she's sitting in a nest. That's the whole idea behind a nesting score, and you can do it from the other side of the fence with your coffee in your hand.

The score is a quick visual check of how well the bedding lets a calf burrow in and trap warm air around her body. Higher scores mean more bedding wrapped around her legs, which means less body heat going into the ground. It costs nothing, takes no equipment and beats guessing by feeling the straw with your glove.

Most of the trouble with calf bedding isn't that nobody put any in. It's that somebody put some in two days ago and the calf has since flattened it into a pancake.

What the score actually measures

A newborn calf has very little body fat and a thin coat, and she's wet when she hits the ground. Cold air isn't the only thing pulling heat off her. Cold, hard ground and damp bedding do just as much, because heat leaves by direct contact. The Dairyland Initiative at UW-Madison puts it plainly for nursing calves: in winter, sufficiently deep bedding, particularly straw, is a must so the calf can "nest" and trap a layer of warm air around herself, with a clean calf jacket added for extra warmth if needed.

Nesting scores turn that advice into something you can see. The scale used in calf housing work runs from 1 to 3. I'm giving it from memory, so check it against your own extension or vet material before you train your crew on it.

ScoreWhat you seeWhat it means
1Calf lying on top of the bedding; all four legs clearly visibleToo shallow or too packed. Add bedding now.
2Legs partly covered; you can still see the lower legsFine in mild weather. Marginal in a hard cold snap.
3Legs buried; the calf looks like she's sunk into the strawThis is the target when it's cold.

Score the calf that is lying down, not the one standing up and looking at you. Standing calves tell you nothing about the bed. And score before feeding, because a fed calf that just flopped down is a different calf than one that has been lying for an hour.

How to do a quick check on the whole row

The point of the score is speed. Pick a time, same time each day, and run the row.

  1. Walk the hutch row or pen line and look at each calf that is lying down.
  2. Give each one a 1, 2 or 3 in your head or on a clipboard.
  3. Mark any hutch that scores a 1 and add bedding on the spot, not at the end of the chores.
  4. Do the knee test on any hutch that scores a 3 but looks suspect: kneel on the bedding for about 20 seconds. If your knee comes up wet, the bed is deep but soaked, and that's worse than shallow and dry.
  5. Write down the problem hutches so you can see if the same ones keep coming up.

The same hutch scoring a 1 three days in a row usually isn't a bedding problem. It's a drainage problem, a roof leak or a hutch sitting where the wind drives rain right in the door. If you've fought the same wet spot all winter, where you put the hutches deserves another look before you buy more straw.

Straw, shavings or sand: what nests

Not every bedding nests. Long, coarse straw is what calves burrow into, and it traps air between the stems. Fine sawdust and shavings tend to lie flat and absorb moisture, so calves sit on them instead of in them, and you'll see a lot of 1s even with a respectable layer. Sand drains well and stays cleaner, but it doesn't insulate, so in a cold climate it's not the winter answer on its own. Comparing straw, sand and shavings goes through each option, including what works when straw prices make you flinch.

If you're stuck using shavings, you can still score and still improve the bed. Put a deeper layer in at the back of the hutch, add a layer of straw on top and re-score. Nobody has to tell the calf which material is the fancy one.

When to add bedding

There's no calendar answer, because the right amount depends on the weather, the calf's age and how much she wets the bed. As a rough guide:

  • Newborns in a freezing week. Check twice a day and top off whenever the legs show.
  • Mild weather. A score of 2 is usually fine as long as the bed is dry.
  • Hot weather. Nesting matters less. The Dairyland Initiative notes that in summer a dry, clean bed of straw, sawdust or shavings is fine. Your job there is dry and clean, not deep.
  • A scouring calf. Change bedding more often, deep or not. Wet, fouled straw is a disease reservoir, and the calf is losing fluid already.

Add on top rather than stripping the whole thing each time. Fresh straw over a dry base keeps the nest intact, and you only pull the whole bed when it's wet through or between calves, when the hutch gets cleaned anyway.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Scoring in a wet bed and calling it good. A 3 on soaked straw is a cold, wet calf in a deep hole. Always pair the score with a dry check.
  • Letting the bedding sit in the door. Calves kick the bed out the entry and end up with a bare spot where they lie. Rebuild the dam at the front.
  • Using nesting score as the only cold-weather plan. It tells you about the bed. It says nothing about wind, a wet newborn or how much energy she's getting. Those need their own fixes, covered in keeping newborn calves warm in winter.
  • Putting the best bedding where it's easiest to reach. The calves in the far hutch don't know they're far.

Cold-weather success has a lot to do with energy too. A calf that is fed enough and kept dry has a much easier time staying warm than one that's skimping on both. A calf coat can add warmth on top of a good bed, and whether calf coats pay depends on your climate and how well you keep them clean.

Where to read more

The Dairyland Initiative's nursing calf housing page covers hutch bedding, placement and cleaning schedules in more detail. The Dairy Calf and Heifer Association also publishes best-practice resources, and your herd vet can help you build a simple scoring routine into the daily walkthrough.

Quick answers

How deep should calf bedding be?

Deep enough that a lying calf's legs disappear into it, which in a cold snap is usually several inches of long straw that has been fluffed rather than packed. In mild or hot weather, a clean, dry bed is enough. Depth matters less than whether it stays dry.

Can calves have too much bedding?

Rarely in cold weather, though it can pile up in the doorway and make it hard for a young calf to get in and out. If the bedding is deep but wet, the problem is moisture, not depth.

Does the nesting score matter for calves in a barn?

Yes, though the score may run lower in a barn that stays warmer. Calves in an enclosed barn still lose heat to a cold, damp floor, so the quick look is worth doing anywhere the air gets cold.

More from farm.FM Need a break from the paperwork? Farm humor and funny farm stories are always in season at farm.FM.