Dairy Hub

Breeding, Genetics & Reproduction

Best Dairy Breed for a Family Cow

Dairy heifers in a show ring

A family cow is a long commitment with a very large animal. She needs milking twice a day, doesn't take weekends off and will eat a surprising amount of hay in February. So the best family milk cow isn't the one that wins at the fair. It's the one you can handle, feed and live with.

For most homesteads the short list is Jersey, Guernsey, Brown Swiss, Milking Shorthorn and a few crosses. Jerseys are the popular pick because they're small, make rich milk and need less feed. Brown Swiss and Holsteins give a lot more milk than a family can use. Guernseys and Milking Shorthorns often land in the sweet spot. Within any breed, though, the individual cow's temperament and udder matter more than the label.

Below is how to match a breed to your space, your family and your appetite for cream.

How much milk does your family really need?

Start with the number, because this decides more than breed does. A cow can give several gallons a day at peak, and a household of four doesn't drink that. Excess milk means calves, pigs, cheese, butter, a neighbor with a bucket, or a lot of waste. A smaller cow, or one that gives moderate volume for a long time, often suits a family better than a high producer.

You can find a realistic estimate in how much milk a family cow gives in a year. If you want to stretch one cow across a busy schedule, once-a-day milking is worth a look, though it reduces total yield.

Breed by breed for the homestead

Jersey

The default family cow, for good reason. Jerseys are small, usually around 900 to 1,000 pounds, rich in butterfat and fairly easy to keep on pasture and hay. They're affectionate and curious. The downsides are real: Jersey cows can be sensitive around fresh time, with a higher risk of milk fever, and Jersey bulls have a dangerous reputation. Keep the bull part of the plan simple by using AI or borrowing a bull you'd never turn your back on. Details on registration and breed information are available from the American Jersey Cattle Association.

Guernsey

Slightly bigger than a Jersey, with rich milk and a mellow reputation. Guernseys can be harder to find, and sire choices are more limited, but a good one is a pleasure in a small barn.

Brown Swiss

Big, calm and strong. Brown Swiss produce plenty of milk with good protein, which makes them popular for cheese. They need more feed and more room than a Jersey, and a 1,400-pound cow who decides she's finished with the milking stand is a lot of cow. The Brown Swiss association can point you toward breeders.

Milking Shorthorn

Calm, dual-purpose and moderate in size. Milking Shorthorns can make decent milk and decent calves, which suits a homestead that wants beef as well. They're a smaller population, so you may have to look further afield for a cow.

Holstein and crossbreds

A Holstein is a lot of cow for a family. If you can get an older Holstein cheap, she may make more milk than you can handle. Crossbreds, such as a Jersey cross, can be good family cows and are sometimes easier to buy. For a bigger comparison of all the breeds, see dairy cattle breeds compared, and for a related look aimed squarely at homesteads, the best breed for a family milk cow covers the same decision from another angle.

Temperament matters more than breed

Every breed has gentle cows and cranky ones. You're going to be standing next to her, twice a day, with your head against her flank. Look for a cow who stands quietly, doesn't kick, and accepts you handling her udder. Ask to see her milked before you buy, and watch how the seller behaves around her. If the owner is nervous, there's usually a reason.

A cow that has been handled and milked by hand since she was a heifer is worth a lot more than a cheap cow with unknown habits. Remember that a nervous new owner and a nervous new cow make two nervous animals in a very small stall.

What to look for when buying

  • Udder. Well attached, balanced, with teats the right size for your hands. Small or oddly shaped teats make hand milking miserable.
  • Health history. Ask about mastitis, vaccinations, and any test results the seller has. Ask about brucellosis and TB status requirements for your state.
  • Milk record. A cow with a known lactation history lets you plan.
  • Age and breeding status. A fresh cow or one due soon will start paying her way. An open cow means waiting.
  • Feet and legs. Lameness is a problem on every dairy, and a family cow who limps to the barn twice a day gets old quickly.
  • Calf. Many family cows come with a calf at side, which is a bonus. Know what you'll do with the calf.

Have your vet do a pre-purchase exam if you can. State animal health rules vary, including health papers, testing and movement requirements, so contact your state veterinarian's office or ag department before moving a cow across a line.

The daily realities

The cow is only part of the plan. You'll need a safe place to milk, clean water, enough hay and pasture, a fence she respects and a back-up person who can milk when you can't. A cow doesn't care that you have a wedding. Keeping a family milk cow covers the full setup, and the daily hand-milking routine shows how to keep milk clean.

One more thing about raw milk: rules on selling or sharing it differ a great deal from state to state, and some states don't allow it at all. If you plan to share or sell milk, check with your state's agriculture or health department first. Milk for your own household is a different matter than milk for the neighbors.

For more on dairy cattle care from a land-grant source, Penn State Extension's dairy section is a solid starting point.

Quick answers

What's the easiest dairy cow for a beginner?

A calm, hand-milked Jersey or Guernsey with a good udder is a common starting point. A gentle older cow with a known history is often easier than a young one with an unknown one.

How many cows does a family need?

One cow often gives more than a household of four can use. A single cow needs company, though, so many families keep her with a calf, a goat or another cow, and plan for what to do with extra milk.

Can I milk a beef cow instead?

Some people do, but beef cows are not bred for milking and may be harder to handle and give less. A dairy breed or dairy cross is a much more reliable choice.

More from farm.FM Need a break from the paperwork? Farm humor and funny farm stories are always in season at farm.FM.