Dairy Hub

Dairy Business, Finance & Labor

How to Find Your Break-Even Milk Price

Tractor and milk tanker at a dairy

Your break-even milk price is the price per hundredweight you need to receive to cover every cost of running the dairy, with nothing left over and nothing owed. Below it, you are losing money. Above it, you are making some. It sounds simple, and then you try to find your own number and discover three of your costs were never written down.

Most farmers carry a rough figure in their heads. It is usually lower than the real one, since the head tends to leave out depreciation, family labor and the loan interest that is quietly eating the profit. This article shows how to build the number properly, so when the milk price moves you know where you stand.

Break-even depends on what you include

There are really three break-even levels, and each one answers a different question.

  • Cash break-even. Covers only the bills you pay out of pocket: feed, labor, vet, fuel, utilities, repairs, supplies, interest and taxes. It tells you the price you need to keep the lights on.
  • Break-even with replacement of equipment. Adds depreciation, which stands in for the money you will need to replace the barn equipment, mixer and parlor eventually.
  • Full economic break-even. Adds a fair wage for unpaid family labor and management, and sometimes a return on the capital you have invested. This is the price at which the dairy truly pays its way.

A farm can survive below the full break-even for a while by working for free and letting the equipment age. It cannot do that forever. Knowing which level the milk price covers tells you how much trouble you are in.

Step 1: Add up a year of costs

Use a complete year of records. Include every category on the dairy side of the farm:

  1. Feed: purchased feed, mineral, and the cost to grow your own forage and grain, including seed, fertilizer, fuel, custom work and land rent.
  2. Labor: wages, payroll taxes, insurance and benefits.
  3. Herd expenses: veterinary, medicine, breeding, supplies, DHI testing, hauling and marketing fees.
  4. Bedding, utilities and fuel.
  5. Repairs and maintenance on buildings and equipment.
  6. Insurance, property taxes and professional fees.
  7. Interest on every loan.
  8. Depreciation on buildings, equipment and breeding stock if you count it.
  9. An allowance for unpaid family labor and management.

If you also raise crops to sell or run another enterprise, separate those costs so they do not distort the dairy. This is where decent records pay for themselves, and what to track and where explains how to set that up.

Step 2: Subtract non-milk income

Dairies earn money from more than milk. Cull cows, calves, bull calves, crop sales and patronage refunds all bring in cash. Subtract these from your total costs, since they pay part of the bill. What is left is the amount the milk itself has to cover. Be realistic here. Cull cow prices move, and a one-time windfall should not make your break-even look better than it is.

Step 3: Divide by hundredweight sold

Take the cost the milk has to cover and divide it by the total hundredweight shipped in the year. The result is your break-even milk price per hundredweight.

A worked example with round numbers

These round numbers are only here to show the arithmetic, so do not read them as typical of any real farm. Suppose a herd ships 20,000 hundredweight in a year. Total costs, including depreciation and a fair wage for family labor, come to $560,000. Cull cows, calves and other non-milk income bring in $90,000. That leaves $470,000 for the milk to cover. Divide $470,000 by 20,000 and the break-even is $23.50 per hundredweight.

Now compare it with your average price received. If the milk check averages $25.00, you are $1.50 ahead on every hundredweight, which is $30,000 over the year. If it averages $22.00, you are $1.50 behind and $30,000 short. Run it with your own figures in a spreadsheet and the picture gets clear quickly, whether you like it or not.

The cost of production per hundredweight article covers the same calculation in more detail and helps you check which costs to include.

Step 4: Compare it with the right price

Use the net price you actually receive, after hauling, deductions and any premiums, not the headline price from the news. Your milk check shows what lands in the bank. The blend price explains why that figure differs from a single class price.

Then run it both ways. What is your margin at the current price? What is it if the price falls by a few dollars? What price would you need to pay all the bills and take a reasonable wage? Those three numbers together tell you far more than one.

Where farmers go wrong

  • Leaving out family labor. The farm may feel profitable because nobody is being paid. That is not the same as profit.
  • Ignoring depreciation. Equipment wears out, and the loan on its replacement will not care that you skipped it on paper.
  • Mixing enterprises. Hay sold off the farm or a beef side business can blur the dairy numbers.
  • Using a single great year. A year with unusually high cull cow prices or unusually low feed costs flatters the result. Average a few years if you can.
  • Counting heifers twice. Raised replacements are a cost when you raise them. Do not count them again as purchases.
  • Quitting after the first pass. The first number is rarely right. The second is better, and the third is something you can trust.

Using the number

Once you have it, the break-even is a decision tool. It helps with:

  • Price protection. If the forward price or Dairy Revenue Protection level sits above your break-even, locking it in may be sensible. If it sits below, you are insuring a loss.
  • Expansion and investment. A new barn or robot has to bring the break-even down, not just add cows.
  • Culling and herd decisions. Cows with low production and high health costs push your break-even up.
  • Lender conversations. A farmer who knows the number leads a better meeting.

A margin protection program such as Dairy Margin Coverage works off a national formula, not your own cost, so comparing it with your break-even tells you how well it fits. For help with benchmarking against similar herds, ask your land-grant university's dairy farm business specialists, such as the University of Wisconsin Extension dairy program.

Quick answers

Should I include my own pay in the break-even?

For a full economic break-even, yes. Many farms track both a cash break-even without it and a full one with a reasonable wage, so they know the difference between surviving and thriving.

How often should I recalculate my break-even?

At least once a year, and any time feed costs, interest rates or herd size change a lot. A quick update every quarter keeps it useful.

Is a lower break-even always the goal?

Generally yes, though not at the expense of cow health or milk quality. Cutting costs that hurt production or animal care usually raises the break-even later.

More from farm.FM Need a break from the paperwork? Farm humor and funny farm stories are always in season at farm.FM.