Dairy Hub

Breeding, Genetics & Reproduction

PTA Explained: Dairy Genetics for Beginners

Dairy heifers in a show ring

PTA stands for predicted transmitting ability, and it's an estimate of how much better or worse a parent's offspring will be than average for a given trait, because of the genes that parent passes along. Each parent gives half of its genetics to a calf, so a PTA is half of an animal's estimated genetic merit. That's why a bull with +1,000 pounds of milk PTA is expected to produce daughters that average about 1,000 pounds more than the base, not 2,000.

Every PTA also has a reliability figure, which says how much to trust it. Together those two numbers are the foundation of every sire summary, every cow genetic report and every genomic test result. Once they make sense, the rest of the catalog gets much less intimidating.

No math degree required. If you can compare two cows by their milk records, you can compare two bulls by their PTAs, and you'll probably argue about it at the feed store with the same enthusiasm.

What a PTA actually tells you

A PTA compares an animal to a genetic base. A bull with a PTA of +500 pounds of milk is expected to sire daughters who, on average and under the same conditions, produce about 500 pounds more milk in a lactation than daughters of a base-level bull. A PTA of zero means average for the base, and a negative number means below it.

Two things trip people up.

  • It's about daughters (or offspring), not the animal herself. A cow's own record reflects her genes and her environment, including the ration, the barn and how often someone forgot her at the headlock. A PTA is an attempt to pull out the genetic part.
  • It's an expectation, not a guarantee. Individual daughters vary a lot around the average. A good PTA improves the odds, it doesn't put a ribbon on any particular calf.

Lower is sometimes better

For most traits, bigger is better. For a few, smaller is better. Somatic cell score is the main example: a lower score is a sign of better udder health, so you want a negative PTA. The same idea applies to some calving and stillbirth traits, where lower percentages are better. Always check which direction is good before you rank anything, because you don't want to find out at calving time that you picked the wrong end of a scale.

Reliability: how sure is the number?

Reliability is expressed as a percentage, and it reflects how much information was used to calculate the PTA. A bull with thousands of daughters in many herds has a very high reliability. A young bull who's only been genomically tested has a much lower one, because the estimate is based on his DNA and his ancestors rather than on actual daughters.

A higher reliability means the PTA is less likely to change. A lower reliability means it could move, sometimes quite a bit. That doesn't make young bulls a bad idea. It means you should spread your bets across several, so one bad surprise doesn't ruin a year of breeding. It also means you should not compare a high-reliability bull and a low-reliability bull as though their numbers were equally firm.

Parent average versus genomic

Before genomic testing, a young animal's PTA was basically the average of her parents' PTAs, which left her with a modest reliability. Genomic testing adds DNA information that sorts out which half of each parent's genes she actually inherited, and that raises reliability a good deal. Genomic testing heifers looks at whether that improvement is worth paying for in your herd.

Where PTAs come from

In the US, national genetic evaluations of dairy cattle come from the Council on Dairy Cattle Breeding working with the USDA Agricultural Research Service. The USDA Animal Improvement Program describes the research partnership behind those evaluations. The evaluations use records from herd milk testing, breed association registrations and genomic data submitted by AI companies and farms, which is why consistent record keeping and registration matter.

Traits are updated several times a year as new daughter and genomic information arrives, so a bull's PTA can shift between summaries. Small changes are normal. A big drop in a bull with high reliability is rare and worth asking about.

PTA, index and other numbers on the page

TermWhat it isDirection
PTAPredicted transmitting ability for a single traitDepends on the trait
Reliability (REL)How much information stands behind the PTAHigher is firmer
Index (NM$, TPI, JPI)Many PTAs combined into one rankingHigher is better
Somatic cell score (SCS)Udder health traitLower is better
Daughter pregnancy rate (DPR)How quickly daughters get pregnantHigher is better
Sire calving ease (SCE)Ease of birth for calves sired by the bullLower is easier

A single trait PTA is only part of the story. Indexes combine many PTAs, and Net Merit versus TPI covers how the main ones differ. For an applied walk through a catalog page, see how to read a sire proof.

Using PTAs on your own cows

PTAs aren't just for bulls. Cows and heifers have them too, particularly if you've registered them or done genomic testing. Ranking your own animals lets you decide which cows to breed for replacements, which to breed to beef and which to move down the list. If you want to sort heifers that way, using genomics to pick which heifers to keep picks up where this article leaves off.

Remember that a cow's PTA is not the same as her performance. A cow with a high PTA for milk who's had a bad lactation because of a displaced abomasum is still a cow with good genes. And a cow with a modest PTA who's milking well because she's in a great pen is still a cow with modest genes. Both pieces of information are useful, and neither replaces the other.

Common beginner mistakes

  • Reading PTA as the amount the cow will produce, rather than the difference from a genetic base.
  • Forgetting that lower is better for some traits.
  • Comparing PTAs across different breeds without noting that each breed has its own base.
  • Ignoring reliability and assuming every number is equally solid.
  • Expecting PTA differences to show up in a single daughter. It's an average across many.
  • Assuming the genetic part of a cow is the whole part. Feed, comfort and fresh cow health still pay most of the bills.

Quick answers

Why is a PTA half of the animal's genetic value?

Because each parent passes on only half of its genes to a calf. The PTA estimates what a parent transmits, which is half of what it carries.

What is a good reliability for a bull?

Proven bulls with many daughters have high reliability. Young genomic bulls have less, and that's a trade-off many herds accept for faster genetic progress, as long as they use several bulls.

Do PTAs apply to every breed the same way?

The idea is the same, but each breed is evaluated against its own base. A Jersey and a Holstein with the same milk PTA aren't expected to give the same amount of milk, and you shouldn't compare numbers across breeds directly.

More from farm.FM Need a break from the paperwork? Farm humor and funny farm stories are always in season at farm.FM.