Breeding, Genetics & Reproduction
Choosing a Dairy Sire: How to Read a Sire Proof

An AI catalog sire page is a wall of abbreviations, and the trick to reading it is to ignore most of it at first. Pick the one index that matches your goals, set a floor for the health and fertility traits you won't compromise on, check reliability, and only then look at the rest. A bull who clears those gates is usually a fine bull. A bull who doesn't is usually pretty on a page and a headache in the barn.
The numbers themselves aren't hard. Most of them are PTAs, predicted transmitting abilities, which estimate how his daughters will differ from the breed base for each trait. A positive number is above the base. For traits where lower is better, like somatic cell score, a low number is the good one, and that's where most beginners get tripped up.
Here's a plain-language tour of the page, in the order that tends to save money.
Start with your goal, not his picture
Before you open a catalog, write down what the next generation of cows needs to do. A herd shipping fluid milk on a component-based check, a cheese plant herd, a grazing herd on seasonal calving and a small family dairy that wants easy-keeping cows are all different. The same bull can be a great fit for one and a poor one for another.
That's why indexes exist. They bundle many traits into one number weighted by what the index designers think matters economically. Net Merit versus TPI compares the main ones. Pick one that fits your goals and use it as your ranking tool, then use individual traits as filters.
Reliability: how much to trust the number
Every PTA comes with a reliability figure, shown as a percentage. It tells you how much information sits behind the estimate. A young genomic bull with no daughters yet may have a moderate reliability, based on his DNA and his pedigree, while a bull with hundreds of milking daughters in many herds will have a high one.
High reliability means the number is unlikely to move much. Lower reliability means it could move up or down. That doesn't mean you should avoid young bulls. Plenty of herds use them heavily and spread the risk across several sires, so one surprise doesn't sink the whole group. What it does mean is that you shouldn't put all your cows on one new bull because his summary looks great. PTA explained for beginners goes deeper on what reliability really measures.
The main groups of traits
Production
Milk, fat and protein pounds, and the percentages for fat and protein. If your milk check pays on components, the weight you put on fat and protein matters more than raw milk volume. Check your handler's pricing to see how much components pay in your order. The USDA AMS federal milk order pages explain the framework, and your cooperative or processor can explain how it applies to you.
Health and longevity
- Productive life (PL): how long daughters are expected to stay in the herd and milk.
- Somatic cell score (SCS): lower is better, a rough guide to udder health.
- Livability and health traits: calf and heifer livability, and direct health traits for things like mastitis, metritis and retained placenta, where available.
Fertility
Daughter pregnancy rate (DPR) is the headline trait: higher means daughters tend to get pregnant faster. Heifer and cow conception rates help too. Fertility has a low heritability, so progress is slower than for milk, but it adds up over generations and it pays you back in fewer days open. The fertility traits get their own treatment in sire fertility traits like DPR.
Calving traits
Sire calving ease (SCE) tells you how easily calves sired by that bull are born, which is the one that matters for heifers. Daughter calving ease (DCE) tells you how easily his daughters will calve when they're mature. Stillbirth figures are paired with these. If you've ever pulled a big calf out of a small heifer at 2 a.m., you already know why the heifer pen wants a calving ease bull. See choosing calving ease sires for first-calf heifers for the specifics.
Type
Type traits, including udder composite, feet and legs composite and body size, describe the cow's conformation. Udders and legs matter because a cow who can't walk to the parlor or hold a udder together doesn't last. Don't overpay for show type if you aren't showing, though. A bull's pretty pedigree won't make your milk check go up.
Genetic recessives and inbreeding
Many catalogs flag whether a bull carries known genetic recessive conditions or fertility haplotypes. The point is to avoid mating two carriers. Most herds just choose non-carriers when they can, and use a mating program to check the pairings. See inbreeding in dairy herds and how to avoid it for how to keep pedigrees from tightening up.
A simple way to screen bulls
- Choose your index and set a minimum score you won't go below.
- Set floors for fertility (DPR), productive life and somatic cell score so you don't buy a high-index bull with a hole in one of them.
- Set a calving ease limit for sires used on heifers.
- Check reliability and spread your risk. Use several bulls rather than one, particularly young ones.
- Run the shortlist through your mating program for inbreeding and recessive carriers.
- Compare the price of the semen against the genetic gain, not against the price of last year's.
If someone tells you there's a bull who'll deliver a cow that gives premium milk, stays healthy for years and handles the paperwork, this farm.FM piece on dairy breeding experts promising a cow that also understands the tax code is worth a laugh before you sign anything. The real catalog doesn't list an accountant trait yet.
Where the numbers come from
US genetic evaluations for dairy cattle are produced through the Council on Dairy Cattle Breeding, working with the USDA Agricultural Research Service. The USDA's Animal Improvement Program describes that research partnership and the evaluation work behind the traits you see in a catalog. Individual AI companies then package those numbers, add their own indexes and rank their bulls, so it's worth looking at the underlying PTAs and not just the marketing label.
Common mistakes
- Chasing the top of the list for milk alone, and paying for it later in fertility and health.
- Ignoring somatic cell score because it's lower-is-better and feels backwards.
- Putting every heifer on the highest-index bull without checking his calving ease.
- Falling for a single outlier trait and forgetting the index.
- Using one bull on the whole herd. That's genetic eggs in one basket.
Regional differences
Heat tolerance and udder health traits can matter more in the Southeast and Southwest. Grazing herds in the Northeast, Upper Midwest and elsewhere often lean toward lower-maintenance, smaller cows with good fertility and components, and some use crossbreeding. Large Western dairies may emphasize production, feed efficiency and health traits. Ask your AI representative which bulls perform well under conditions like yours, and check results from herds near you.
Quick answers
What does a positive PTA mean?
It means daughters are expected to be above the breed base for that trait. For traits where lower is better, such as somatic cell score, a negative number is the good direction.
Should I only use high-reliability bulls?
Not necessarily. Proven bulls are safer, and young genomic bulls can move the herd faster. Many herds mix both and use several sires so one surprise doesn't hurt much.
Which index should I follow?
The one that matches how you're paid and what your cows need to do. Compare the index descriptions, pick one, and stick with it for at least a few breeding cycles.