Dairy Hub

Breeding, Genetics & Reproduction

What One Extra Day Open Costs a Dairy Cow

Dairy heifers in a show ring

Nobody can hand you a single honest number for what an extra day open costs, and anyone who does is probably selling a heat detection system. Published estimates vary a lot from herd to herd, and they're all right for the herd they were figured on. What matters is your number, and you can get it with a pencil, a milk price and a candid look at your records.

Here's the part that stings. Days open cost you money on cows you can see (the ones milking at a lower level than they could be) and on cows you can't (the ones culled early, the calves that never got born on schedule). The first is easy to spot. The second hides in the cull report and gets blamed on bad luck.

So this article is about building the calculation yourself, using your own milk check, and then deciding which cows are worth chasing.

Where the cost comes from

An extra day open doesn't send you a bill. It shows up as four slow leaks.

  • Lower average milk per day. A cow who calves later spends more of her lactation in the declining tail of the curve. Her total milk for the year is lower because there are fewer fresh-cow days where she's near peak.
  • Fewer calves. A longer interval means fewer calves per cow per year, which touches replacement supply and whatever your calves bring.
  • More reproductive culls. Cows that stay open long enough often leave the herd for it, and replacing a cow costs a lot more than keeping a good one a few more weeks.
  • More breeding expense. Extra semen, extra hormones if you use them, extra vet time, extra labor on cows that keep coming back.

The first two are slower and quieter than the last two, which is why herds underrate them. Penn State Extension points out that failing to detect heat in a timely and accurate way causes excessive days open and long calving intervals, and calls this economically important in its overview of systematic breeding programs.

A worked example (use your own numbers)

The figures below are made up to show the method. Swap in yours.

Say a cow's best days are well behind her and she's now milking a bit under the herd average. Suppose pushing her calving date back a full month means she loses a handful of pounds of milk per day averaged across the extra stretch, and she eats close to the same feed regardless. Multiply the lost milk by your net milk price, subtract any feed or cost differences, and spread the result over the extra days. That gives a rough per-day figure for that cow.

Then add in the other leaks. If extended days open make a cull more likely, estimate the chance and multiply it by the difference between what a cull cow brings and what a replacement costs. Spread that over the same period. You'll likely find that culls and calf value dwarf the milk effect for cows who are far out, and that the milk effect dominates for cows who are only a bit late.

That's the whole trick. It's not complicated, it's just tedious, which is why it rarely gets done. Most of us would rather rebuild a gate hinge than open a spreadsheet, and the hinge at least stays fixed.

The inputs worth gathering

  1. Your net milk price per hundredweight after hauling and deductions, not the number on the headline.
  2. Typical milk per day at the stage the cow would be at if she'd calved on time, compared with where she is now.
  3. Feed cost per cow per day.
  4. Current cull cow price and what it costs you to bring in or raise a replacement.
  5. Value of a calf, which differs a lot between a heifer calf, a bull calf and a beef cross.

The cost is not the same for every cow

A day open is not worth the same on every cow, and that's good news. A cow who's milking well, is healthy and just hasn't settled yet may be worth the extra days if she's close to getting pregnant. A cow who's open at 200 days and still milking mediocre is a different story: the longer she waits, the less she's worth to you.

First-lactation cows are a special case. They're still growing, they usually peak a bit lower, and their later days open tend to cost less per day than a mature cow at peak. But letting them drift also delays the whole herd's generation interval, which matters if you're trying to pick the best heifers to keep.

For some herds the smartest thing is to split cows into groups: those worth another breeding, those to switch to beef semen and breed once more, and those to cull while they still have a market. Putting names on those groups every month beats arguing about it once a year.

Where to find the days

You can't save a day open by wishing. You save it by changing something upstream. The usual suspects, in rough order of payoff:

  • Heat detection that actually works. If your system catches half the heats, you're losing a lot of cows to a three-week delay each time one is missed. How to detect heat in dairy cows is the place to tighten up, and it's usually cheaper than a new gadget.
  • Conception. Cows that are bred on time and don't settle still cost you days. Compare your numbers against conception rate benchmarks before deciding where the problem is.
  • Pregnancy checks. The sooner you know a cow is open, the sooner you can rebreed. Pregnancy checking methods compares ways to do it and how early each one works.
  • The cows that keep coming back. A cow bred three or four times without a calf has a story. Repeat breeder causes and fixes is a good starting point before you decide she's a cull.

And yes, the vet will have opinions. That's what the vet is for. A herd with a persistent breeding problem needs a reproductive health review, not a new heat detection gadget bought on a Tuesday.

Mistakes that make the number look better than it is

  • Averaging only the cows that got pregnant. The ones that were culled open never show up in the average, so the average flatters you.
  • Using the headline milk price instead of your net price.
  • Ignoring the calf. A late calf is a calf you don't have on the day you needed it.
  • Comparing your herd to a published figure from a very different production system. A grazing herd on seasonal calving has a different math from a confinement herd on rolling calving.
  • Treating all open cows as equal. Fresh cows still inside the voluntary waiting period aren't a problem. They're not eligible yet.

Where regions differ

Hot, humid summers in the Southeast and desert heat in the Southwest push conception down, so the cost of a day open is partly a cost of the weather. Herds there often decide that a day saved through cooling is worth more than a day saved through another round of hormones. In the Upper Midwest, heat detection is helped by cooler weather but hampered by slick floors in winter. For grazing herds with a compact calving window, a cow that misses it often costs more than a day: she may cost a whole year of production, because she'll need to wait for the next block.

Quick answers

What's a reasonable cost per day open?

There's no single honest figure, because it depends on milk price, feed cost and cull rate in your herd. Run the calculation with your own numbers and treat borrowed averages as a rough sanity check only.

Is it ever worth leaving a cow open longer?

Yes, for a healthy cow who's still milking very well and close to conceiving. It stops being worth it when she's open and sliding down the lactation curve without a plan.

How do I cut days open fastest?

Fix heat detection or move to a timed breeding program, check pregnancies at set intervals, and rebreed open cows quickly. Those three changes usually beat any single expensive purchase.

More from farm.FM Need a break from the paperwork? Farm humor and funny farm stories are always in season at farm.FM.