Breeding, Genetics & Reproduction
Net Merit vs TPI: Picking a Dairy Selection Index

Net Merit and TPI are both selection indexes, which means each one takes dozens of trait evaluations and boils them down to a single ranking. They disagree on the recipe. Net Merit is expressed in dollars and is built around expected lifetime profit. TPI, the Total Performance Index, is expressed in points and puts more weight on type than the dollar-based indexes do. A bull can rank very high on one and merely good on the other.
Neither one is wrong. They're built on different assumptions about what a cow should do, so the right one for you depends on how you're paid and what kind of cow you want to be milking in five years. Pick one, use it consistently, and don't spend your evenings agonizing over a bull who's third on one list and ninth on the other. The cows will not be able to tell the difference, and they have no vote.
Below, what each index tries to do, where they differ, and how to use them without letting a single number run your herd.
What Net Merit is
Net Merit dollars, written NM$, is the national lifetime profit index published through the Council on Dairy Cattle Breeding (CDCB), with USDA research behind it. The value is expressed in dollars, representing the expected difference in lifetime profit of a bull's daughters compared with the base. If one bull is +800 and another is +600, the first is expected to leave daughters that earn about 200 dollars more, over their lives, than the second's, assuming the economic weights hold.
The index puts weight on milk components (fat and protein), productive life, daughter pregnancy rate, somatic cell score, calving traits, and a set of health and efficiency traits. It's updated from time to time as economics and the available data change, so the weights in use at any moment aren't necessarily the ones a bull was ranked on when you first looked at him. The CDCB also publishes variations aimed at different markets, such as cheese, fluid milk and grazing herds. Those are worth a look if your milk goes to a cheese plant or if you graze, because they weight components and efficiency differently. The background research is described on the USDA Animal Improvement Program page.
What TPI is
TPI is the Holstein Association USA's index. It's expressed in points rather than dollars, and it combines production, health and fertility, and type traits into one number. Its distinguishing feature is that it carries a meaningful weight on conformation, including udders and feet and legs, in addition to production and fitness traits. Holstein breeders who care about type and show-ring credibility often favor it, and many AI companies list it prominently in their catalogs.
The Jersey breed has a parallel index in the Jersey Performance Index (JPI) from the American Jersey Cattle Association, and other breeds have their own. If you milk something other than Holsteins, check what your breed association publishes.
The differences in plain terms
| Feature | Net Merit (NM$) | TPI |
|---|---|---|
| Published by | CDCB, with USDA research | Holstein Association USA |
| Units | Dollars of expected lifetime profit | Points |
| Emphasis | Components, health, fertility, longevity, efficiency | Balanced across production, health and fertility, and type |
| Type weight | Lower, mostly through traits tied to longevity | Higher, with direct conformation traits |
| Applies to | Multiple breeds through the national system | Holsteins |
| Best fit | Commercial herds focused on profit per cow | Registered herds, show herds and breeders who value type |
In practice, the two indexes are strongly correlated. A bull who ranks near the top of one is usually well up on the other. The disagreements show up in the details, usually when a bull is exceptional for type but only average for health, or the reverse.
Which should you use?
If you're a commercial herd selling milk
Net Merit, or one of its market-specific versions, usually fits best because it was built around profit. Match the version to your market: a cheese-plant herd might lean on cheese merit, a grazing herd on a grazing-oriented index. Start there, then apply floors for traits you won't compromise on.
If you're a registered Holstein breeder
TPI is common because it ties to the Holstein Association's registry and sales culture, and because buyers often ask about it. Many breeders who care about type use TPI as their main sort, and check Net Merit as a second opinion to make sure they aren't paying for a pretty cow with a short life ahead of her.
If you milk Jerseys, Brown Swiss, Ayrshires or crossbreds
Check your breed association's index and the CDCB's national evaluations. Dollar-based national indexes apply across breeds, but weights were designed with a Holstein-dominated population in mind, so a breed with different component profiles may need a second look. Holstein versus Jersey is a reminder that the breeds are paid differently by the same milk check.
How to use an index without being used by it
- Pick one and rank with it. Switching indexes every sale catalog just means you're chasing the newest brochure.
- Apply floors. Set minimums for daughter pregnancy rate, productive life, somatic cell score and calving ease. Detail on those is in how to read a sire proof and sire fertility traits.
- Look at reliability. An index is only as good as the information behind it, which is the subject of PTA explained.
- Don't chase the top of the list. Differences among the top handful of bulls are small compared with the uncertainty in their numbers.
- Watch inbreeding. Popular high-ranking bulls share ancestors, and using them heavily can tighten pedigrees faster than people expect.
Mistakes to avoid
- Treating NM$ like a guaranteed paycheck. It's an expected difference, not a promise, and your management and feed matter at least as much.
- Assuming a higher TPI means a more profitable cow in your barn. It may, but check the health and fertility numbers behind it.
- Buying semen on the strength of one trait that happens to match a show winner.
- Ignoring your own herd's problems. If you've got a mastitis headache, a somatic cell score floor will do more than another 100 points of index.
- Letting the neighbor's choice settle yours. He's got a different milk check, a different barn and, probably, a different opinion about everything.
Regional notes
In hot regions such as the Southeast and Southwest, fertility and heat tolerance are worth special attention, and a bull with top production but poor fertility can cost you more than he earns. Upper Midwest and Northeast herds often care about longevity and udder health for tie-stall and freestall barns. Large Western dairies tend to focus on production and feed efficiency. Grazing herds in many regions favor smaller cows with good components and strong fertility. In every region, your own milk check and your own problems should drive the weights you put on each trait.
Quick answers
Is Net Merit or TPI better?
Neither is better in the abstract. Net Merit is built around profit, TPI gives more weight to type, and the best one is the one that matches how your herd earns its living. The two tend to agree on the top bulls.
Can I use both indexes?
Yes. Many herds rank on one and use the other as a cross-check. If a bull is great on one and mediocre on the other, find out why before buying.
Do indexes change over time?
Yes. The weights are revised periodically as economics and available data change, and bull rankings shift as new information arrives. That's why one bull's index can move between summaries.