Dairy Hub

Breeding, Genetics & Reproduction

Sire Fertility Traits: Daughter Pregnancy Rate and More

Dairy heifers in a show ring

A sire can look great on a milk and type sheet and still leave you a pen full of daughters that won't settle. Fertility traits are the part of the proof that tells you how a bull's daughters are likely to get back in calf, and they're the numbers most people skim past on the way to the production columns.

The headline trait is daughter pregnancy rate, usually shortened to DPR. It's an estimate of how a sire's daughters will do on the same 21-day yardstick that your herd uses to measure pregnancy rate. A sire at plus 1.0 is expected to produce daughters whose pregnancy rate runs about one percentage point higher than daughters of an average sire, and a sire at minus 2.0 is expected to run about two points lower. That sounds small until you remember how many 21-day cycles a low-fertility cow burns through.

The short version: put real weight on DPR, look at the other fertility and survival traits beside it, and don't let one flashy milk number talk you out of it. Here's how the pieces fit.

What DPR actually tells you

DPR is a predicted transmitting ability, the same kind of number as every other trait on the sheet. If you need a refresher on reading those, PTA explained for beginners covers what the plus and minus signs mean and why a sire's number is only half of the story. A bull passes on half his genes, and the cow supplies the rest and then lives in your barn, with your feed and your heat detection.

Because DPR is measured in daughters' real-world pregnancy performance, it's driven by things like how soon cows show heat after calving and how often they hold to a service. It does not guarantee anything about a single cow. What it does is shift the odds across a lot of daughters, and you only milk a lot of daughters if you keep using the sire.

If your herd's own pregnancy rate is a mystery, sort that out first. Pregnancy rate in a dairy herd, explained walks through how to calculate it so you know whether genetics is even your biggest problem. Sometimes the bull is blameless and the real culprit is the person who stopped walking the pen at five in the morning.

The other fertility traits worth a look

DPR gets the attention, but several related numbers show up on most proofs and are worth reading together.

  • Cow conception rate. An estimate of how well a sire's lactating daughters conceive when bred. Higher is better.
  • Heifer conception rate. The same idea for heifers. A bull can look better or worse here than with cows, and the two don't always line up.
  • Sire conception rate. This one is different. It describes how well the bull's own semen performs when it's used, not how his daughters will breed. A bull with great daughter fertility and weak semen fertility is a headache you'll feel at the tank.
  • Productive life. How long daughters tend to stay in the herd, which is fertility's quiet partner. A cow that won't breed gets culled long before she pays back her raising costs.
  • Livability and stillbirth traits. These estimate calf survival around birth and, in some evaluations, cow survival too. A fertile sire that throws a lot of dead calves hasn't done you much good.

Names and exact versions of these traits change over time as evaluations are updated, so check the current definitions from the evaluation source or your AI company's sire catalog and don't rely on an old summary sheet taped inside the tank room door.

Where fertility sits in a selection index

You probably don't select on DPR alone, and you shouldn't. Most herds use a total merit index, and fertility is already folded in. How much weight it gets differs between indexes, which is the whole argument in Net Merit versus TPI. If your breeding problems are bad, you can pick a sire list from your index and then screen it with a fertility floor, such as dropping anything below zero on DPR, and see how many bulls survive.

A few cautions apply when you screen:

  • Don't set the bar so high that you only have three bulls to choose from. Inbreeding creeps in fast. Inbreeding in dairy herds explains why a long list of related sires is its own kind of problem.
  • Young genomic sires have wider reliability ranges than proven bulls with large daughter groups. A genomic DPR is a good estimate, but a bull with thousands of daughters has had a long time to prove it.
  • Don't overreact to one bad run of breedings. Heat, transitions and mastitis scrambled conception long before you looked at the bull.

Fertility problems that genetics won't fix

Genetics moves slowly. A bull you choose today affects heifers that won't calve for roughly two years and milk for several more. That's a long time to wait on a problem you could partly fix this week.

Poor fertility in a herd usually has several roots at once: a rough transition period, cows too thin or too fat at calving, heat stress, uterine infections, missed heats, a thawing mistake at the tank, or a breeding schedule that keeps missing the same window. Pick fertile sires, yes, but also run a fresh cow program that keeps metabolic and uterine problems under control. Sire fertility is a slow, cheap, long-term lever. It does not replace the daily ones.

Regional conditions matter too. In hot parts of the Southeast and Southwest, cows fight heat stress for months, and the fertility traits that look similar on paper in a Wisconsin freestall may translate differently in a Texas dry lot. Grazing herds with a tight seasonal calving window have even less room for slow breeders, because a cow that calves late may not get a second chance in the next cycle. If that's you, fertility should carry more weight than the average herd gives it.

A simple way to use fertility traits on your next sire list

  1. Start with the total merit index that fits your milk market and herd goals.
  2. Set a minimum for DPR, and a minimum for the survival or livability traits you care about.
  3. Check sire conception rate on any bull that makes your short list, so you aren't buying poor semen fertility with good daughter fertility.
  4. Match sires to the cows. Fertility is not the only reason to use a bull, and heifers have different needs than mature cows; calving ease sire selection for heifers covers the other side of that coin.
  5. Spread the picks across several bulls and write down who you used so you can look at daughter results later.

If you'd like a deeper walk through the proof sheet itself, how to read a sire proof is the place to start. For university-backed material on dairy genetics and reproduction, Penn State Extension's dairy pages and Cornell PRO-DAIRY both publish practical reproduction and breeding resources.

Quick answers

What is a good DPR for a sire?

Anything above zero means daughters are expected to breed back better than the average sire's daughters. Many herds that struggle with fertility screen for a clearly positive number, but the right cutoff depends on how many bulls it leaves you to choose from.

Is DPR the same as my herd's pregnancy rate?

No. Your pregnancy rate comes from your barn's actual breeding results, while a sire's DPR is a genetic estimate of how his daughters will perform relative to other sires. A good sire helps, but management still drives most of the day-to-day result.

Should I sacrifice milk for better fertility?

You usually don't have to give up much. A total merit index already balances the two, and you can find bulls that are strong on both. Just don't pick the highest milk bull on the list and hope the fertility figures itself out.

More from farm.FM Need a break from the paperwork? Farm humor and funny farm stories are always in season at farm.FM.