Dairy Hub

Youth, Shows, Careers & Dairy Life

Manure Pit Gas Dangers and Confined Space Safety

Youth dairy show lineup

Most farm hazards give you a little warning. A cow with her ears pinned tells you what she's about to do. A pit full of manure gas does not. It can take down an experienced hand in a breath or two, and the person who rushes in to help is often the second one down.

So here is the short version for any dairy family, including the teenagers who think a pit is just a big hole with a lid. Gas builds up in stored manure and is released when you stir it or pump it. Some of it has no smell, and one of the worst ones can dull your sense of smell right when you need it. Nobody climbs into a pit or tank. Nobody goes after a victim without proper rescue gear and training. You call 911 and you stay out.

Your own barn dog has better instincts about this than most of us. The rest of this article is about turning that instinct into a rule that holds up at six in the morning when somebody drops a phone down a hatch.

What's actually in a manure pit

Manure stored without much air keeps breaking down, and it gives off gas while it does. The ones that matter on a dairy are hydrogen sulfide, methane, carbon dioxide and ammonia. They behave differently, which is why one rule of thumb ("I'd smell it") fails.

  • Hydrogen sulfide smells like rotten eggs at low levels. At higher levels it can overwhelm the sense of smell, so a pit that suddenly "smells fine" may be the worst one. It can cause collapse very quickly.
  • Methane has no smell, burns, and can push oxygen out of a closed space.
  • Carbon dioxide is heavier than air and settles low in tanks, pits and corners.
  • Ammonia burns the eyes, nose and throat, and it's usually the one that makes you leave before the others get you.

The riskiest moments are agitation and pump-out, when stirring breaks the crust and shakes gas out of the slurry. The Iowa State Extension Safe Farm series covers this under the title manure storage poses invisible risk, which is about as short a summary of the topic as anyone has managed. Utah State's extension farm safety pages also cover confined spaces and other farm hazards in plain language you can hand to a new hire.

Why a pit is a confined space

A confined space is a place that's big enough to get into, hard to get out of, and not built for people to hang around in. Manure pits, below-barn storages, pump-out tanks, wet wells and some silos all fit. The air inside can lack oxygen, hold toxic gas, or both. You can't see it, and you can't judge it by standing at the hatch.

Real confined space entry involves testing the air, forced ventilation, a trained person outside, rescue equipment on hand and written procedures. A typical dairy doesn't run that program for routine work, and shouldn't pretend to. Anything that requires going in, such as cleaning a tank, repairing a pump or retrieving a dropped tool, belongs to a contractor who does this for a living. If the tool is the problem, the tool is gone. Buy another one.

The rescue trap

Confined space incidents have a grim pattern. One person goes down, a second goes in to help, and a third follows. The urge to help is strong and fast, and the gas doesn't care about either. The plan has to be made before anyone is in trouble:

  1. Call 911 first. Say it's a manure pit and a confined space emergency so the right rescue team responds, and give the farm address and the way in.
  2. Increase fresh air from outside if you can do it safely, such as opening doors or turning on fans away from the hatch. Don't lean over the opening to look.
  3. If the person is at the opening and you can reach them with a rope, pole or hook without putting your head in the space, that may be an option. If it requires you to enter or breathe the air from the pit, it doesn't.
  4. Keep everybody else away, including the kids, and have someone meet the ambulance at the road.

It feels wrong to stand still while a family member is down there. Know that going in without breathing apparatus is the most common way to turn one emergency into two.

Family rules that work

Safety posters on the wall don't stop anyone. Rules that everyone can recite, and that apply to the owner too, do. Try a short list like this one and review it at the kitchen table, not just at the pit.

  • Nobody enters a pit, tank or manhole. Ever. That includes the owner and anybody who says they'll just be a second.
  • Nobody works at a pit alone, and somebody always knows when agitation starts and ends.
  • Before agitation, move people and animals out of the barn when the system calls for it, and open every curtain, door and fan path you can. Ask your installer or equipment dealer what the plan is for your barn, because layouts differ.
  • Gas monitors get calibrated and tested on the maker's schedule. A monitor in a drawer with a dead sensor is a very expensive paperweight.
  • Covers, grates and slat openings stay in place. If one goes missing, it's an emergency, not a to-do item.
  • Kids and visitors stay clear of tanks and lagoons. The dairy farm safety rules for kids and teens are a good place to start the conversation about what's off-limits and why.

Where regions and barns differ

Below-barn pits are common in the Upper Midwest and Northeast, where cold winters push manure storage under the building. Agitation there lets gas come up through the slats into the room where cows and people are, and weak winter airflow makes it worse. If you're sorting out how to run the barn in January, the notes on winter ventilation bear directly on this.

In large Western and Southwest dairies, manure often goes through flush systems and open lagoons, with pump stations and settling basins that have their own hazards. The risk shifts from the barn to the pump pit and the edge of the lagoon. Your system choice matters, too. Flush, scraper and robot systems put gas in different places, and the same goes for how you handle sizing manure storage when it's built or expanded. A grazing herd with a small pit has a smaller version of the same problem, and a smaller version is still enough.

Training everybody, not just the owner

Most crews have people who learned their farm safety in a different country, in a different language, on a farm with a different kind of pit. Give instructions in the language people use at home, show them the actual hatch, and make sure it's understood that stopping work is always allowed. The practical bits are in training dairy crews in Spanish, and the existing piece on manure pit gas safety for dairy crews goes through the agitation checklist step by step.

Then rehearse. Walk through who calls, who meets the truck, where the monitor lives and what the road address is. A five-minute run-through twice a year costs less than the monthly feed bill for one cow and is worth more than most of what's on the shelf in the shop.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Trusting your nose to tell you the air is fine.
  • Letting one person handle agitation while everyone else assumes they have it covered.
  • Reaching down to grab a dropped phone or tool "just for a second."
  • Skipping the plan because it's never happened here. That is how it first happens anywhere.

Quick answers

Can I go into a manure pit if I hold my breath?

No. Gas can overcome you faster than you expect, and you'd have to climb back out while impaired. If something must be retrieved or repaired, a contractor trained in confined space work should do it.

What should I tell 911 if someone collapses in a pit?

Say it's a manure pit and a confined space emergency, give the exact address and entrance, and tell them what you know about the person. Then stay out of the space, keep others away and meet the responders.

Do I need a gas monitor on a small dairy?

If you agitate or pump manure near a barn, a calibrated personal monitor for hydrogen sulfide, oxygen and combustible gas is a sensible tool. Ask your extension safety specialist or equipment dealer what fits your setup, and follow the maker's directions for testing it.

More from farm.FM Need a break from the paperwork? Farm humor and funny farm stories are always in season at farm.FM.