Dairy Hub

Dairy Business, Finance & Labor

Dairy Farmers Never Retire, But a Plan Helps

Tractor and milk tanker at a dairy

Ask a dairy farmer when he's retiring and you'll get a laugh, a shrug, or "when they carry me out." Farmers don't leave a job. They leave a way of life that includes the house, the land, the cows, the neighbors and about forty years of habit. That's why so many put off the question until a bad back, a bad diagnosis or a bad milk price makes the decision for them.

A plan doesn't mean stopping tomorrow. It means knowing what income you'll live on, which jobs you'll hand off first, who is taking over what, and where you'll live. Done early, it lets you step back slowly. Done late, it happens in a hospital waiting room with the lender on the phone.

Why the question keeps getting postponed

It's not just stubbornness. A dairy is a business, a home and an identity all in one. Selling or handing it over can feel like giving up the one thing you're good at. There's also money: the farm is usually worth a lot on paper and the farmer has little in retirement accounts. The land is the retirement fund, and you can't spend a piece of it without affecting everything else.

A Center for Retirement Research blog post on a survey of Wisconsin farmers, Retiring From Farming Is Complex and Not Always Planned, found that most respondents, whose average age was 63, had not figured out when they'd retire, and fewer than half had a firm plan for passing on the farm. The same post said the farmers were counting on some form of federal retirement or health benefit, yet seven in ten had not yet contacted the Social Security Administration. Those numbers come from one state's survey, but any dairy family can recognize them. If retirement still feels like a punchline, farm.FM's page of farmer jokes is a fair place to start, so long as you move on to the paperwork before the coffee gets cold.

Step one: figure out what you'll need

Write down the real monthly number. Not the dream version, the one that covers groceries, health insurance, property taxes, vehicle costs, medications, and whatever else shows up when you're no longer on the farm payroll. If you plan to keep living in the farmhouse, who pays for upkeep and utilities? If someone else farms the place, is the house part of the deal?

Then list possible income sources:

  • Social Security. Farm owners are generally treated as self-employed and pay into it, but your benefit depends on your reported earnings history. Create an account with the Social Security Administration and check the estimate. Claiming age changes the monthly amount, so talk with an advisor.
  • Medicare and health coverage. Many farmers buy individual health insurance before 65. Learn the Medicare enrollment rules ahead of time, since late sign-up can have penalties. Medicare.gov is the official source.
  • Retirement accounts. Self-employed retirement plans exist, and money added in the years before you step back helps, even if it feels small next to land values.
  • Rent from land, buildings or equipment. Leasing cropland, barns or the parlor to a successor or neighbor creates income without selling.
  • A wage or management fee. If you stay on to help the next generation, pay should be spelled out.
  • Proceeds from selling the herd, equipment or part of the land. Taxes matter a great deal here, including capital gains and recapture of depreciation, so speak to a tax advisor first.
  • Installment sales or buyouts to a family member or partner. These can provide a steady stream, but they need strong legal documents. See where to start with dairy succession planning for how the pieces fit.

Step two: step back in stages

Most farmers do better with a ramp than a cliff. One way to build it:

  1. Pick the chores you're willing to give up first. Often it's the early-morning milking, then field work or feeding, then maintenance. Hold on to jobs you enjoy longest.
  2. Write down who does what. A one-page list of tasks and owners is a surprisingly effective peacemaker.
  3. Move decisions in stages too. Let the next person make small purchases, then herd decisions, then bigger financial ones, with agreed limits.
  4. Pay everyone fairly. If the next generation is working for low wages or none, resentment is a matter of time. Bringing the next generation into the business covers partnership structure.
  5. Hold regular family meetings. Ten minutes of calm conversation beats a decade of silence. A simple family meeting agenda for succession helps keep it from turning into a food fight.
  6. Set a trial date. Agree to review the arrangement after six months or a year, and adjust without blame.

The unglamorous truth is that the hardest part isn't the milking. It's watching somebody else do it slightly differently and keeping your mouth shut. You can have an opinion; you just have to schedule it for the meeting.

This is where an attorney and an accountant earn their fees. Topics to cover include a will, powers of attorney, health care directives, entity structure, a buy-sell agreement if partners are involved, and the tax effects of any transfer. Estate planning basics for a dairy farm family lists the documents and questions that come up most. If an outright sale or wind-down is on the table, planning a dairy exit covers timing and sequence.

Be careful about "fair versus equal." If one child farms and others don't, an equal split of the farm can wreck the business, and an unequal split can wreck the family. There's no formula. There are options, such as leasing to the farming child, giving non-farming heirs other assets, or insurance. A farm-experienced attorney and a mediator can help when the conversation stalls.

Plan for health, too

Dairy work is physically demanding, and it can end suddenly. Think about disability coverage while you're still working, long-term care options, and what happens if one spouse can't work. A plan that assumes good health until 80 isn't a plan, it's a hope. Include a list of who has authority to act if you can't, and make sure the next generation knows where documents are kept.

What if there is no successor?

That's common. Options include selling to a neighbor, renting the farm to a beginning farmer, selling the land and dispersing the herd, or an arrangement that lets a non-family farmer build equity over time. Each has trade-offs, and each takes more lead time than people expect. Start earlier than feels necessary.

Quick answers

When should a dairy farmer start planning retirement?

Ideally ten years or more before the date you have in mind, since land, equity and succession arrangements take time to arrange. If you're closer than that, start now anyway and work in stages.

Can I keep farming part-time after handing off the dairy?

Many farmers do, in roles like calf care, crop work or equipment maintenance. Put the arrangement in writing, including pay and decision authority, so it doesn't turn into confusion.

Who should be on my retirement planning team?

A farm-experienced accountant, an attorney who handles farm succession and estates, your lender and a financial planner you trust. Your extension office can often point you to programs and advisors who specialize in farm transition.

More from farm.FM Need a break from the paperwork? Farm humor and funny farm stories are always in season at farm.FM.