Dairy Hub

Dairy Business, Finance & Labor

Estate Planning Basics for a Dairy Farm Family

Tractor and milk tanker at a dairy

An estate plan is the set of documents that says who gets what, who makes decisions if you can't, and how the farm keeps running when you're gone. Most dairy farmers have a will drafted years ago, a vague plan in their head and a lot of faith that the kids will sort it out. The kids, for the record, will not sort it out.

The basics are simple to list: a will, usually a trust of some kind, a durable power of attorney, a health care directive, beneficiary designations that match the plan, and a business structure that makes sense for a farm with a herd, machinery and land. The details depend on your state and your family, so this is a job for an attorney who handles farm estates. What follows is what to understand before the first appointment.

Why a dairy is a hard case

A dairy is a lot of value tied up in things that can't be sliced. Land, barns, a parlor, a herd, machinery, feed stores and co-op equity make up most of the net worth, and there's often not much cash. That creates the classic farm estate problem: land-rich, cash-poor, and several heirs, only one or two of whom actually milk cows.

If the farm has to be sold to pay what each heir is owed, the family loses the business that built the wealth. A good plan is mostly about avoiding that.

The core documents

  • Will. Directs who inherits what you own in your own name and names an executor. A will usually goes through probate, which is a public court process and can take time. Time is not a friend of a herd that needs milking tomorrow morning.
  • Revocable living trust. Holds assets during your life and passes them on according to the trust terms without going through probate. Many farm families use these, but a trust only controls what has been retitled into it.
  • Durable power of attorney. Names someone to handle financial and business matters if you're incapacitated. Without one, a court may have to appoint a guardian or conservator. Nobody wants a judge deciding who signs the milk contract.
  • Health care directive and medical power of attorney. Names who speaks for you on medical decisions and records your wishes.
  • Beneficiary designations. Retirement accounts and life insurance pass by the name on the form, no matter what the will says. Check that they match your plan.
  • Business entity documents. If the farm is an LLC, partnership or corporation, the operating agreement or bylaws control what happens to ownership interests. See buy-sell agreements for dairy partners and family for how those fit in.

Fair is not the same as equal

This is the heart of most family fights. Suppose one child stayed and milked cows for twenty years for modest pay, and two others moved away and built careers. Splitting everything in three equal parts is equal. Is it fair? Many families decide that the working heir should get the operating assets, and the others should get something of comparable value from other assets, from life insurance, or through a payout over time.

There's no single right answer, and what counts as fair is a family conversation before it's a legal document. Questions worth settling:

  • Who is actually going to run the dairy, and are they willing and able?
  • Should land stay in the family while the operating business goes to the working heir, with a lease between them?
  • How will off-farm heirs be treated, and do they understand what the farm can afford?
  • What credit does the working heir get for years of below-market pay and sweat equity?
  • What about a child who worked on the farm but won't be taking it over?

These conversations go better when they're held on purpose and not at the funeral. Running a family business meeting on the dairy gives you an agenda and ground rules for it.

Taxes, in general terms

Tax rules here change and depend on your state, so this is general education only. Three areas tend to matter for farms:

  • Federal estate and gift taxes. Federal rules include an exemption that is large for many families, but farm values can be high, and some states have their own estate or inheritance taxes at lower thresholds. The IRS explains the basics on its estate tax page and the related gift tax page.
  • Valuing farmland. There are provisions in the tax code that may let qualifying farmland be valued by how it's used and not by what a developer would pay. They come with conditions, so a tax professional needs to check them.
  • Income tax basis. How inherited assets and gifted assets are treated for later sale differs. Gifting during life and passing at death produce different tax results.

Your CPA and attorney need to work together on this. A good plan from the attorney that ignores the tax return is a plan with a surprise in it.

Long-term care and retirement

Farm families often forget to plan for the owner's own care. If a nursing home stay costs a large share of your assets, it can eat into what the next generation was counting on. Talk to an elder law attorney about options. Also plan for the retirement income of the older generation; dairy farmers never retire, but a plan helps has ideas for stepping back without turning off the lights.

Insurance and liability

Life insurance can provide the cash that the farm does not have, whether to pay taxes, equalize an inheritance or fund a buyout. Check that policy ownership and beneficiaries are set up on purpose. Your general liability coverage matters too, because a lawsuit can undo a plan quickly. The farm liability insurance guide covers what to review.

Steps to get started

  1. List all assets and debts, and how each is titled.
  2. Write down what you want to happen to the farm, in order of priority.
  3. Talk with your family, starting with the likely successor.
  4. Find an attorney experienced with farm estates and, if possible, a CPA who works with farms.
  5. Draft documents, sign them, and put copies where someone can find them.
  6. Review the plan after any major event, such as a birth, death, marriage, divorce or sale of land.

For a broader picture of how this fits with transferring the business itself, see dairy farm succession planning. Extension and farmland organizations also publish free worksheets for farm transfer; the American Farmland Trust's Farm Transfer Action Plan is one of them.

Quick answers

Is a trust better than a will for a dairy farm?

It depends. A trust can avoid probate and provide for continued management, but it costs more to set up and only works if assets are retitled into it. An attorney can help decide based on your state, your family and the farm's structure.

What happens to the farm if I die without a will?

State intestacy law decides who inherits, and it may split the farm among heirs in ways you wouldn't choose. Probate can also leave the operation without clear authority for a time. A basic will plus a power of attorney is the minimum.

How often should I update my estate plan?

Review it every few years and after any major change in family, finances or farm ownership. A plan drafted before a new partner, a divorce, a large expansion or a new grandchild may no longer say what you want.

More from farm.FM Need a break from the paperwork? Farm humor and funny farm stories are always in season at farm.FM.