Dairy Hub

Dairy Business, Finance & Labor

Dairy Farm Succession Planning: Where to Start

Tractor and milk tanker at a dairy

Most dairy farm succession plans never get written. They live in a few heads, get discussed at Christmas for ten minutes, and are then put back on the shelf next to the owner's manual for the bulk tank. The farm keeps running, the cows keep calving, and nobody wants to be the one to bring it up.

Then something forces the issue: a health scare, a death, a sibling who wants out, a lender asking pointed questions. A farm that gets handed off in a crisis loses money, time and sometimes the family. A farm that gets handed off on a plan usually keeps all three.

This article is about where to start, not about the legal details. Succession is part family conversation, part business plan and part tax and legal work. Do not skip any of them. When it comes to the legal and tax pieces, you need an attorney and an accountant who work with farms.

Start with what each person actually wants

Before anyone draws up a chart, find out what every person involved wants. That includes the owners, the children who work on the farm, the ones who live elsewhere, and the spouses, whose opinions matter more than anyone admits.

  • Does the owner want to keep milking cows until he cannot, or step back in five years?
  • Does the child on the farm want to own it, manage it, or work for wages?
  • Do the siblings off the farm expect an equal share, or something else?
  • Is anyone hoping the farm gets sold?
  • What does the owner need to live on for the rest of his life, and where will it come from?

These are hard questions, and the answers are sometimes uncomfortable. Better they come out now than at the reading of a will. A written list of goals, one page per person, is a good first exercise.

Understand fair versus equal

This is where many dairy families get stuck. A farm is usually the bulk of the family wealth, and it cannot be cut up like a pie. One child works the farm for decades, another becomes a nurse in another state. Splitting the farm equally can leave the farming child with a debt load that shuts the dairy down. Giving it all to the farming child can leave the others feeling robbed.

There are ways to be fair without being equal. Life insurance, off-farm assets, buy-out terms over time and a farm-for-wages arrangement can all balance the books. The right answer depends on the family. The point is to have the conversation openly, and the article on running a family business meeting on the dairy gives a structure for it.

Take inventory

You cannot plan the transfer of something you have not measured. Pull together:

  1. A current balance sheet with land, buildings, herd, equipment, feed inventory and debts.
  2. Ownership documents: who holds title to the land, what entity owns the cows, what leases exist.
  3. Income and expense records for several years, and a clear view of what the farm really earns. The financial benchmarks every dairy farmer should track help here.
  4. Existing wills, trusts, powers of attorney and insurance policies.
  5. Contracts: milk handler agreements, leases, equipment loans.
  6. A list of what only the owner knows: which cow has a temper, which pump needs a kick, who the good vet is, what the handler rep's cell number is.

That last item is not a joke. Many dairies run on knowledge that exists only in one person's head, and transferring it takes years. Writing it down, including simple SOPs for milking and calf care, is a head start for the next manager.

Separate the management transfer from the ownership transfer

These are two different handoffs, and they rarely happen on the same day. Management means who makes the daily and strategic decisions. Ownership means who holds title to the land, herd and business. A successor can take over management years before getting ownership, building a track record and learning the finances.

A gradual approach is common: the next generation starts with wages, takes on a share of the herd, buys into the business over time, and eventually takes over land and decision-making. The details belong in written agreements, and the next generation partnership article covers how to structure that.

Build the team

Succession needs several professionals, and each plays a role:

  • An attorney familiar with farm estates and business entities.
  • An accountant who understands farm tax issues, including how transfers, sales and gifts are taxed.
  • A lender, since the successor will probably need financing.
  • An insurance or financial advisor for life insurance, retirement income and long-term care.
  • A facilitator if the family cannot talk without the dishes flying. Many extension services and farm transition programs offer them.

Free resources exist. The Farm Answers clearinghouse collects materials from USDA-funded beginning farmer programs, and the Farmland Information Center has material on farm transfer and land access. Your state extension office may run its own transition workshops too, which tend to be cheaper than the attorney's hourly rate.

Document it

A verbal agreement made over a cup of coffee in the milk house is not a plan. Memories differ, families change and people die. Written agreements should cover who owns what, who gets paid what, what happens if someone wants out, and what happens if someone dies or becomes disabled. A buy-sell agreement is one tool, and a will and basic estate planning are others. Taxes and legal structure vary by state, so involve professionals in your state.

A rough timeline

  1. Now: Start the conversations and write down goals.
  2. Within a few months: Gather the inventory and meet with an advisor team.
  3. Within the first year: Draft a transition outline: roles, timeline, financial needs of the retiring generation.
  4. Over several years: Transfer management and ownership in steps, revisiting the plan regularly.

Dairy transitions usually take longer than anyone predicts. Starting early, even when the owner is healthy and in no hurry, is the best advice anyone gets on the subject. The same is true for retirement planning itself.

Quick answers

When should a dairy family start succession planning?

As soon as possible, ideally years before anyone wants to step back. Starting early gives the next generation time to learn and the senior generation time to plan its income.

Do we need a lawyer for farm succession?

Yes, an attorney who works with farm estates and business structures is a key part of the team. Laws and taxes vary by state, so ask for experience with farms in yours.

What if the children do not want to farm?

Then the plan changes, but it still needs to exist. Options include selling, renting out the land, bringing in a non-family successor or a gradual wind-down, and the dairy exit plan article covers those paths.

More from farm.FM Need a break from the paperwork? Farm humor and funny farm stories are always in season at farm.FM.