Dairy Hub

Milk Markets, Co-ops & Processing

Making and Selling Butter From Farm Cream

Cheese aging in a creamery and a milk tanker

Butter is just cream that has been agitated until the fat clumps together and the buttermilk separates. That part is easy and old as the dairy barn. The harder part is doing it in a way that is safe, consistent and legal enough to sell. Cream is perishable, butter is a regulated product with a legal definition, and most states want to know about it before it shows up at the farmers market.

So the plan has two halves: the craft of making good butter, and the paperwork that lets you sell it. If you only want butter for your own table, the piece on making butter from your own cream covers the home version. This article is about turning that into a product.

The basic process

  1. Separate the cream. A cream separator pulls cream from the milk, and many small farms use one. Gravity separation also works, though it is slower and less consistent.
  2. Heat treat or pasteurize the cream. Most commercial butter is made from pasteurized cream, and many states require it for butter sold to the public. Cream is usually pasteurized at higher temperatures than milk because of its fat content, so confirm the process with your regulator and the equipment maker.
  3. Cool and ripen. Cream is chilled and, for cultured butter, held with a culture to develop flavor. Sweet cream butter skips the culture.
  4. Churn. The cream is agitated until the fat globules collect into butter grains and the buttermilk drains off. Churns range from a countertop stand mixer to a barrel churn.
  5. Wash and work. Rinsing with cold water removes leftover buttermilk, which matters because buttermilk left in the butter spoils it. Working the butter squeezes out remaining moisture.
  6. Salt, if desired, and package. Wrap or tub it, label it and get it cold.

Butter takes a lot of cream. As a rough rule, a gallon or so of cream makes a few pounds of butter, but yield depends on the fat content of the cream and your process. Keep records and use your own numbers.

Equipment worth having

  • Cream separator (small hand or electric models exist for farm use).
  • Approved pasteurizing equipment if you are selling. A vat is usually the fit for small volumes, and the guide to choosing a pasteurizer goes through the options.
  • Churn or mixer. A food-grade stand mixer works at small scale. Larger churns suit regular production.
  • Stainless bowls, paddles and butter molds.
  • Thermometer you trust.
  • Scale and packaging supplies. Net weight is part of the label.
  • Cold storage. A good cooler, and a delivery plan that keeps butter cold.
  • Sanitizing supplies. If it touches butter, it gets cleaned and sanitized.

Butter has a legal definition

Butter is among the dairy products with a federal standard of identity. From memory, the standard calls for a minimum of 80 percent milkfat, and a product that does not meet it cannot be sold as butter. Penn State extension's page on dairy food standards explains how standards of identity work and where to find them. Confirm the specifics for your product with your state regulator.

Licensing

Selling butter usually means selling a processed dairy product, and your state will probably want an inspected facility and a license or permit. Some states put butter under the same rules as other manufactured dairy products, and some have different categories. The process of getting a dairy processing license is the same general path.

Raw cream and raw milk butter

Whether you can sell butter from unpasteurized cream depends heavily on your state, and some states prohibit it. The FDA's page on the dangers of raw milk notes that raw milk can carry germs that make people sick, and products made from it carry the same concern. Ask your regulator whether raw milk butter can be sold in your state, and do not assume that a friend's farm is operating legally.

Labeling

A butter label commonly needs the product name, net weight, ingredients (including salt, if added), the name and address of the maker, any allergen statement and perhaps a state license number. The labeling rules for farm bottlers give a feel for how these requirements work, though the exact rules for butter come from your regulator and the FDA's labeling regulations.

Making it pay

Butter has a few things going for it. Customers recognize it, it keeps longer than fluid milk when handled properly, and it makes a good add-on to cheese or milk sales. It also has costs. Cream is the highest-value part of your milk, so every pound of butter takes cream you could have sold some other way. Work out the numbers using your own milk price and component values. The butterfat versus protein pricing piece helps you see how your milk is valued, and the comparison of dairy add-ons shows how butter stacks up next to yogurt, ice cream and cheese.

Buttermilk is a bonus, not a waste product. Real cultured buttermilk or sweet buttermilk can go into baking, feeding calves or pigs, or into products of its own, though anything you sell for people to eat needs the same licensing and handling as the butter.

Butter, as a hobby that got out of hand

Butter has a showier side too. If you want a reminder that dairy folks can turn a block of butter into a sporting event, this farm.FM piece on butter carving as a competitive sport among dairy farmers treats it as a serious contest. Your customers will be happy with a plain, well-made pound, though a cow stamped on the top never hurts at the farmers market.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Selling butter from a home kitchen without checking the licensing rules.
  • Leaving buttermilk in the butter. It shortens shelf life and invites off flavors.
  • Using cream that was held warm or too long. Start with cold, fresh cream.
  • Guessing at labeling. Printing 5,000 labels with the wrong wording is a pricey way to learn.
  • Forgetting the cold chain. Butter softens in a truck bed faster than you expect.
  • Ignoring the cost of cream in your pricing.

Quick answers

Can I sell homemade butter at a farmers market?

In most states, only if it is made in a licensed facility and labeled correctly. Cottage food laws often exclude dairy. Check with your state dairy or food agency before you sell.

Do I have to pasteurize cream to make butter for sale?

Many states require pasteurized cream for butter sold to the public, and some prohibit raw cream butter entirely. Ask your state regulator what applies to you.

How long does fresh butter keep?

It depends on how well the buttermilk was removed, whether it is salted, the cream quality and how cold it is kept. Salted butter generally keeps longer than unsalted. Your regulator or a food scientist at your extension office can help you set a safe shelf life.

More from farm.FM Need a break from the paperwork? Farm humor and funny farm stories are always in season at farm.FM.