Barns, Cow Comfort & Equipment
Compost Barn Troubleshooting: Wet Pack and Smell

When a compost pack goes wrong, it announces it. The surface turns sticky, cows come out of the pen with dirty sides, and the barn smells like something you would rather not have named after you. Most of the time the cause is one of five things: too many cows, too little bedding, not enough stirring, a leaking waterer, or air that is not moving.
Work through them in order. Start by squeezing a handful of the pack, since extension guidance says that if water drips out, it is too wet and needs bedding, and if it will not form a ball, it is too dry. Then look at the stocking, the waterers and the airflow before you buy a different tiller or blame the sawdust.
What a healthy pack looks like
You will troubleshoot better if you know what normal is. A working pack is crumbly and warm below the surface, with a dry-looking top layer that does not stick to cows after they rise. It does not mean a smell-free barn, but it should smell earthy, not sharply of ammonia or sourness. Extension sources suggest moisture in a range of roughly 40 to 65 percent, and the stirring is what keeps oxygen in. For the basics of design and routine, read how to build and run a compost bedded pack barn.
Problem 1: the pack is wet and sticky
Wet is the number one complaint. The University of Wisconsin Dairyland Initiative lists the usual causes: not enough bedding, too little space per cow, water spilled from waterers, traffic damage at gates, and poor drainage or ventilation. The fixes follow the causes.
- Check the squeeze test in several places. Test near waterers, gates, the edges and the middle. Wet spots are clues.
- Add dry bedding. Virginia Tech's rule of thumb is to add fresh bedding when the pack is moist enough to stick to cows after they rise. Hot, humid or wet weather needs more frequent additions.
- Review stocking density. Overcrowding adds moisture and can compact the pack, restricting airflow. If you added cows, you added water.
- Look at waterers. Move them to the concrete apron side with a surrounding wall, or fix the leak. A tub that overflows on the pack is a bucket of water added every day.
- Stir deeper or more often. Two times a day is the usual standard, to a depth that actually reaches the wet material.
- Check drainage. Concrete should slope so liquid does not pool in corners.
Do not just keep piling dry bedding over a soaked base. It buys you a few days and costs a lot of sawdust. If the pack is badly gone, some farms clean out part of it and rebuild with fresh bedding, and the herd vet and extension adviser can help decide how far to go.
Problem 2: it smells
Smell usually means the pack is going anaerobic, which means oxygen is not getting in and the wrong microbes are winning. Wisconsin notes that humid air above the pack can carry ammonia and other harmful gases, and that ventilation is the main control. Ammonia is also hard on cow and human airways, so a strong smell is not just a nuisance.
- Increase airflow. Open curtains wider, check that sidewalls are tall enough, and use mixing fans over the pack. Fans must be hung high enough to clear equipment. See how many fans a dairy barn needs.
- Stir more thoroughly. A pack that is compacted or crusted on top will not breathe.
- Cut moisture. A wet pack smells. Dry bedding and fewer cows both help.
- Check bedding type. Wet shavings, straw and green sawdust all cause trouble in compost packs. Virginia Tech and Wisconsin both caution against straw and wet shavings.
Barn smell is also a ventilation report card, and what your barn smell tells you about ventilation goes deeper. Never work in a closed, strongly smelling space without airflow, and if the pack is near manure storage, take gas hazards seriously.
Problem 3: the pack is not heating up or composting
Some farms expect the pack to steam and are disappointed. Wisconsin notes that a common target is about 140 degrees Fahrenheit, but reported averages are lower, around 108, which means the bedding is only partly composted. That is not necessarily failure. The goal is a dry, comfortable surface for cows, not a perfect compost pile. If the pack is cool, wet and sticky, though, stir, dry it and check the moisture.
Problem 4: dirty cows and udder health
If cows are coming out filthy or mastitis cases are creeping up, the pack is too wet or too crowded, or the bedding is the wrong type. Sufficient bedding keeps cows clean and dry, and hygiene scores can tell you how often to add it. Talk to your herd vet and milk quality adviser, since bedding bacteria drive some mastitis cases and the right response depends on the organism. This article is general education; treatment decisions, drug choices and milk withholding belong with your vet. The National Mastitis Council at nmconline.org has background resources.
Problem 5: the pack is too dry or dusty
It happens, especially in hot, dry climates. A pack that will not form a ball when squeezed is too dry, and Sonoma County UC Extension advises waiting to add bedding until moisture comes back up. Dry packs can be dusty, which is hard on cow and worker lungs. Adjust stirring and bedding additions, and check that the pack is not just dry on the surface with a wet layer underneath.
A quick diagnostic order
- Squeeze the pack in five places.
- Count cows against the space you have.
- Check waterers and drainage.
- Check bedding type and dryness in storage.
- Check stirring depth, frequency and timing.
- Check airflow: sidewalls, curtains, fans.
- Look at cow hygiene scores and mastitis records.
Change one thing at a time and give it a few days. A pack is slow to respond, and if you change five things at once you will not know which one worked. The same logic runs through keeping freestall bedding dry and clean, since the moisture problem is the same one in a different outfit.
Regional notes
Humid regions like the Southeast fight moisture all summer, so airflow and fan coverage matter most. In the Upper Midwest and Northeast, cold, wet winters and closed-up barns make winter ventilation the key, and winter ventilation for dairy barns is worth reading before the first cold snap. In dry parts of the Southwest and Mountain West, dryness and dust are the more likely issues. Wherever you are, the Virginia Tech compost bedded pack publication is a good reference to keep handy.
Mistakes to avoid
- Adding more cows to a pack that is already wet.
- Treating a smell as cosmetic. It is information.
- Skipping stirring in cold weather because the tractor is hard to start.
- Using a tiller that only scratches the surface.
- Waiting for it to dry out by itself. Packs do not usually fix themselves, and the neighbors will not mention how it smells to your face.
Quick answers
Why is my compost barn so wet?
The usual causes are too many cows for the space, not enough bedding, leaking waterers, poor drainage and poor airflow. Check each one, starting with stocking density and waterers.
Why does my compost barn smell like ammonia?
Ammonia usually means moisture and poor airflow. Improve ventilation, stir more thoroughly and add dry bedding. Do not enter a closed, strongly smelling space without airflow.
How much bedding should I add to a wet pack?
Add dry bedding until the squeeze test no longer drips water, and keep adding as moisture dictates rather than on a calendar. If it stays wet, the problem is usually stocking, water or airflow, not bedding volume.