Dairy Hub

Dairy Business, Finance & Labor

Choosing Accounting Software for a Small Dairy

Tractor and milk tanker at a dairy

There is no best accounting program for a dairy, only the best one for the person who will actually enter the numbers. Illinois Extension's farm finance educator says it directly: no program meets the needs of all farm operations, and there are dozens of good products to choose from. What matters is picking one your family or bookkeeper will use every week, that your tax preparer can work with, and that your lender will accept reports from.

For a small dairy the choice usually comes down to four questions. Do you want cloud or computer-based software? Do you want something built for farms or a general product? Do you need single-entry or double-entry bookkeeping? And do you keep books on a cash or accrual basis? Answer those and the list of candidates shrinks to a handful.

No endorsements here. Features and prices change, so check each company's current offering before you commit, and ask your tax preparer what they prefer to receive.

The four questions that narrow it down

Cloud or desktop

Cloud programs live on the internet, which means you can enter data from the truck, the kitchen or the vet's parking lot, and your accountant can log in without you mailing a thumb drive. They usually charge a subscription. Desktop programs install on one computer, may be a one-time purchase, and work when the farm's internet does not, a real consideration in places where the signal ends at the mailbox. The Illinois Extension article notes that some popular farm programs are installed on a computer while others are online subscriptions, and that at least one general program offers both.

Farm-specific or general purpose

Farm-specific programs come with income and expense categories that match a farm's tax return, plus features like enterprise reports. General products such as Quicken and QuickBooks are not farm-specific, but you can build farm categories. Illinois Extension names PC Mars and Red Wing as examples built for farm use, and Manager.IO as a general double-entry option with farm-friendly elements. A general product has a larger pool of people who know it, which matters when you need help or a new bookkeeper.

Single-entry or double-entry

Single-entry works like a checkbook: money in, money out. Double-entry records each transaction in two accounts, which allows a real balance sheet and makes it harder for errors to hide. The same Illinois article says Quicken is a single-entry system and QuickBooks is double-entry, and advises asking your accountant or tax preparer which they prefer, which is likely double-entry. Double-entry takes a higher level of accounting knowledge, so be honest about who is going to be doing the work.

Cash or accrual

Most farms use cash-basis records, but accrual changes which programs fit. If you are trying to decide, cash versus accrual accounting on a dairy farm lays out the tradeoffs before you buy anything.

Side by side

Option typeStrengthsWatch for
QuickBooks-style general double-entryBalance sheet, classes or tags for enterprises, wide accountant familiarity, payroll add-onsYou must build the farm chart of accounts; takes some accounting knowledge
Quicken-style single-entrySimple, checkbook feel, easy bank downloadsLimited balance sheet and accrual tools; some preparers prefer double-entry
Farm-specific desktop or cloud programsFarm categories and reports ready to go, built for Schedule FSmaller user base; check that your preparer can import the files
Free or low-cost general double-entryLower cost, can be customizedLess hand-holding; confirm support and update frequency
SpreadsheetFree, flexible, you know it alreadyNo bank feeds, no audit trail, errors multiply, hard to hand to a lender

Illinois Extension also points to bank and credit card downloads as a time saver. You will still need to code each transaction, but typing nothing beats typing everything, and recurring entries stay consistent. Their discussion of features is at Choosing your farm financial records software. Michigan State University Extension also publishes a piece on choosing accounting software for your farm.

Dairy-specific setup that saves headaches

Record the milk check in full

The milk statement shows gross sales, then deductions for hauling, promotion and marketing assessments, co-op or cooperative items, and sometimes capital retains or feed and supply charges run through the plant. Enter gross milk income and each deduction separately instead of only the deposit amount. Otherwise your income looks smaller than it is, your hauling cost disappears and your cost of production per hundredweight stops matching reality. Ask your preparer how they want these items categorized.

Track enterprises

Set up classes, tags or separate accounts for the milking herd, heifers and replacements, and crops. You do not need ten of them. Two or three let you see whether the heifer program or the cropping side is carrying its weight.

Keep a depreciation and livestock list

Software that tracks fixed assets is nice. A spreadsheet maintained by your preparer works too. Whichever you use, the asset list needs purchase date, cost, depreciation taken and disposal. Purchased cows and raised cows are treated differently for tax, so label them.

Use a payroll service or a payroll add-on

Payroll is where a farm gets penalized for small mistakes: wrong deposit schedule, wrong form, wrong classification. Many farm employers file their annual employment taxes on a form that differs from what a non-farm employer files, so ask your payroll provider whether they handle agricultural employers regularly. See dairy employee pay and benefits for what goes on the paycheck besides wages.

How to test before you commit

  1. Ask your tax preparer and lender what they accept and what they like. A program they hate will cost you in fees.
  2. Take a free trial or demo and enter one real month of transactions, including a milk check with every ugly deduction.
  3. Print or export the reports you will need: profit and loss, balance sheet, and a list of transactions by category. Do they look usable?
  4. Check bank feeds with your actual bank. Some small-town banks do not connect cleanly.
  5. Find out how you export your data, because eventually you may switch.
  6. Think about who takes over if you get sick or the bookkeeper moves away.

Common mistakes

  • Buying powerful software no one in the family knows how to use. A complicated system that gets entered once a quarter is worse than a simple one entered weekly.
  • Running everything through a personal account because it is easier.
  • Skipping bank reconciliation, which is how an extra $400 vet bill hides for eight months.
  • Letting the software chart of accounts grow to 200 categories nobody can remember.
  • Forgetting to back up the data file.

Whatever you choose, make it part of a bigger system. What to track and where shows how the books fit with herd and compliance records.

Quick answers

Is QuickBooks good for a dairy farm?

Many dairies use it, and it is a double-entry system that supports balance sheets and enterprise tracking. It is not farm-specific, so you will need to set up farm categories, and it is worth having your accountant help with the chart of accounts.

Can I just use a spreadsheet?

For a very small operation with few transactions, yes, if you keep it disciplined. Spreadsheets lack bank feeds and audit trails and get harder to manage as the business grows, so most farms move to real accounting software sooner or later. The usual trigger is the formula that only one family member understood, right up until he stopped answering his phone during planting.

What should I ask my tax preparer before choosing software?

Ask which programs they are comfortable with, whether they want single-entry or double-entry books, how they prefer milk check deductions categorized, and how they want reports sent at year end.

More from farm.FM Need a break from the paperwork? Farm humor and funny farm stories are always in season at farm.FM.