Dairy Hub

Dairy Business, Finance & Labor

Cash vs Accrual Accounting on a Dairy Farm

Tractor and milk tanker at a dairy

Here is the whole difference in one sentence: cash accounting counts money when it moves, and accrual accounting counts it when it is earned or owed. On a dairy with a milk check that lands on a schedule and a feed bill that arrives whenever the feed truck does, the two methods can tell very different stories about the same year.

Most farms use the cash method for taxes. The IRS Farmer's Tax Guide says most farmers use it because they find it easier to keep records and to reflect income and expenses that way. But "most farms use it for taxes" is not the same as "it is the right way to see how your dairy is doing." Many dairies run the cash method for the tax return and look at accrual-adjusted numbers for management and lending. That is allowed and common, and it is what most of the extension farm finance people recommend.

This article explains the two methods in dairy terms. Tax rules about who must use accrual and how to change methods are technical, so take decisions to a preparer who works with farms.

A checking account balance the day after the milk check clears is not a profit, no matter how good it feels. Accounting methods exist partly to protect you from that feeling.

How each method sees a dairy

ItemCash methodAccrual method
Milk sold in the last two weeks of the year, paid next monthIncome in the year the money arrivesIncome in the year the milk was shipped
Feed bought in the fall and fed over winterExpense when paid, with limits for prepaid feed and suppliesExpense as it is used; the unused feed counts as inventory
Vet bill received but unpaid at year endExpense next year, when you write the checkExpense in the year incurred, with a payable on the books
Bred heifers and milking cowsRaised animals generally have no recorded value on the tax books, purchased ones are depreciatedInventory is tracked; raised livestock can use methods the IRS allows for valuing it
Corn silage in the bunkerNot counted until sold or fed, in most casesCounted as inventory
Timing controlYou can shift some payments and receipts between yearsLess flexibility; income follows when it is earned
Record keepingSimple, checkbook-basedMore work: inventories, receivables, payables

What cash does well and where it misleads

Cash is simple. You deposit the milk check, pay the bills and the books mostly follow the bank. For tax planning it offers flexibility: IRS rules on prepaid farm supplies and prepaid livestock feed let a cash-basis farmer manage income from year to year, within limits. If you need to plan taxes through the year, cash gives you more levers.

The weakness is that cash numbers swing with timing, not performance. Fill the feed bins in December and your cash-basis profit drops. Skip it until January and the same dairy looks flush. Buy a load of heifers and the books show no asset. Take a bank loan and the deposit looks like income unless you code it right. An owner who looks only at cash profit can congratulate himself in a good-timing year and panic in a bad-timing one, with the cows doing exactly the same work.

What accrual adds

Accrual matches income and expenses to the period they belong to. The IRS guide describes the purpose as correctly matching income and expenses in the right tax year. For a dairy that means counting milk when it is shipped, bills when you owe them, and feed, supplies, and sometimes livestock as inventory. It gives a truer picture of profit per year, which is what you need for benchmarking and for figuring your cost of production per hundredweight.

There is a cost. You need good inventory counts, an up-to-date list of what customers owe and you owe, and a system you can maintain. For farm inventories the IRS describes several valuation methods, including a farm-price method and a unit-livestock-price method for raised livestock, and each has rules about how to use it. This is where a farm-savvy preparer earns the fee.

When tax rules push you one way

Several things matter here.

  • Most farms can use cash. The guide says that certain farm corporations and partnerships, and all tax shelters, are generally required to use accrual, but that farm corporations or partnerships under a stated average gross receipts threshold that are not tax shelters can use cash. The threshold is adjusted over time, so ask your preparer what it is for your entity.
  • Inventory can change the picture. If inventories are a significant income factor in your business, the inventory rules need attention. Farm inventory is addressed in its own section of the guide.
  • Different businesses can use different methods. The guide says that if you operate two or more separate and distinct businesses, you can use a different method for each, but each needs a complete and separate set of books. A dairy and an unrelated side business may qualify. A dairy and its own crop acreage almost certainly do not.
  • A combination method exists. The guide describes a combination method that mixes elements of cash and accrual under certain rules.

The IRS Farmer's Tax Guide covers all of this in its chapters on accounting methods; Publication 225 is the place to start reading, and Publication 538 on accounting periods and methods goes further.

Why lenders prefer accrual numbers

A cash-basis tax return leaves out things lenders care about: feed and cattle inventory, money owed to you, money you owe, and prepaid expenses. That is why many loan officers ask for an accrual-adjusted income statement and a balance sheet. The good news is you do not have to convert your books. You keep cash records for taxes and make year-end adjustments to approximate accrual for management and lending. What lenders want in a dairy loan package explains which statements they usually expect, and financial benchmarks every dairy farmer should track relies on the same adjusted numbers.

A basic accrual adjustment, step by step

  1. Start with cash income and expenses for the year.
  2. Add income you earned but have not been paid, such as the end-of-year milk shipments, and subtract anything received during the year that belonged to the prior year's production.
  3. Subtract expenses you paid in advance that belong to the next year, and add bills you owe that belong to the year being closed.
  4. Adjust for the change in inventories of feed, supplies and market livestock from the beginning to the end of the year.
  5. Account for changes in the value of raised breeding livestock only if your system or lender asks for it.
  6. Review with your preparer or farm business advisor.

Switching methods

Changing a tax accounting method is not something you do by simply starting to keep your books differently. The guide discusses changes in methods of accounting and notes that IRS Form 3115 is the application for a change in accounting method, with its own rules and timing. Treat it as a project with a professional, not as something you sort out late on a Sunday night with a pot of coffee and a shoebox. There may be adjustments that move income into one year, so the timing deserves planning, and your accounting software should be able to support the method you choose.

How to decide

  • If you are small, have no lender pressure and simple inventories, cash for taxes with an annual accrual adjustment is the usual answer.
  • If you are growing, borrowing or bringing in partners, accrual-style management numbers become more valuable fast.
  • If your preparer says you are required to use accrual, the question is settled; spend the time on doing it well.
  • If you want the most flexibility on taxes, ask about cash with the prepaid expense rules and a careful plan.

Quick answers

Can a dairy farm use cash accounting?

Most do, for taxes. Certain larger farm corporations and partnerships, and tax shelters, may be required to use accrual, so confirm the rule for your entity with a preparer.

Do lenders require accrual statements?

Many ask for accrual-adjusted income statements and a balance sheet, because cash tax returns leave out inventories, receivables and payables. You can make adjustments from cash books rather than keeping fully accrual books.

How do I change from cash to accrual for taxes?

It requires an application for a change in accounting method, generally on Form 3115, and the rules on adjustments and timing are technical. Work with a preparer who handles farm returns.

More from farm.FM Need a break from the paperwork? Farm humor and funny farm stories are always in season at farm.FM.